legal news


Register | Forgot Password

Laguna Beach Coalition v. City of Laguna Beach CA4/3

Laguna Beach Coalition v. City of Laguna Beach CA4/3
By
10:16:2026

Filed 10/16/26 Laguna Beach Coalition v. City of Laguna Beach CA4/3

NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS

California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication
or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

DIVISION THREE

LAGUNA BEACH COALITION
FOR ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION, G065514

Plaintiff and Respondent, (Super. Ct. No. 30-2023-
01349628)
v.
OPINION
CITY OF LAGUNA BEACH,

Defendant and Appellant.

Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of Orange County,
William D. Claster, Judge. Reversed. Respondent’s request for judicial notice
granted in part and denied in part. Appellant’s request for judicial notice
denied.
Megan K. Garibaldi, City Attorney, and Patrick Donegan,
Assistant City Attorney; Best Best & Krieger, Amy E. Hoyt and Alisha M.
Winterswyk for Defendant and Appellant.
Leibold McClendon & Mann, John G. McClendon, for Plaintiff
and Respondent.
* * *
The City of Laguna Beach appeals from a judgment entered after
the trial court granted a writ of mandate directing it to set aside its approval
of a construction project. The court found the project conflicted with the City’s
general plan, which prohibits development on slopes of 45 percent or greater.
The City raises two issues: (1) petitioner Laguna Beach Coalition
for Environmental Protection failed to exhaust its administrative remedies by
not properly raising the slope issue in the underlying administrative appeal,
and (2) the City reasonably calculated the slope as only 36 percent.
We hold the Coalition exhausted its administrative remedies
because the City was fairly apprised of the slope issue. But because the
general plan’s definition of slope is incomplete and a reasonable person could
have calculated the slope as the City did, we reverse.
FACTS
I.
REGULATORY BACKGROUND
Because this case involves a certain amount of jargon, we begin
by noting some of the City’s land use regulations.
Policy 14-B of the general plan “[p]rohibit[s] hillside development
on slopes of 45% or greater.” (Laguna Beach General Plan Open Space and
Conservation Elements, § III, p. 66.)

2
The general plan also defines “slope.” Under the heading “TOPIC
14: HILLSIDE SLOPES,” the general plan provides: “Slope, simply stated, is
an inclined ground surface, the inclination of which is expressed as a ratio of
horizontal distance to vertical distance. The slope of land may thus be
calculated by dividing the change in vertical distance (rise) by the change in
horizontal distance (run). Although slope may be measured in degrees, ratios
or percent, the latter is most commonly used for land use planning purposes
and is calculated by the formula:

The City’s municipal code defines “Slope in percent.” It provides:
“‘Slope in percent’ means the average of the two corner elevations at the front
property line and the average of the two corner elevations at the rear
property line, with the lower average elevation subtracted from the higher
average elevation, divided by the average depth of the lot.” (Laguna Beach
Mun. Code, § 25.08.034.) The City adopted this definition in a 1989 ordinance
passed “‘to Establish a Consistent Methodology for Building Height’”
regulations. (Laguna Beach Ord. No. 1187.)1 But the definition is codified in

1 The parties request us to take judicial notice of 15 matters total.

The City’s October 22, 2025 request covers four municipal code sections:
25.05.040, 25.07.006, 25.08.004 and 25.10.002. The Coalition’s February 2,
2026 request covers 10 matters: (1) parts of California’s General Plan
Guidelines 2017; (2) the City’s General Plan Open Space and Conservation
Elements; (3) 15 municipal code sections; (4) a September 2024 Public
Records Act request to the City; (5) the City’s September 2024 response to the
request; (6) the City’s “second written response”; (7) the City’s “third written
response”; (8) the reporter’s transcript for the writ petition hearing; (9) the
City’s general plan’s Land Use Element, and (10) a copy of the City’s
Ordinance No. 1187. The City’s March 27, 2026 supplement request covers

3
the general “Definitions and Standards” chapter of the municipal code title
for zoning. It does not state it is limited to slope calculations involving
building heights.
The municipal code also defines property lines. “‘Lot line, front’
means the property line or lines separating a lot from streets in the case of an
interior lot and the line separating the narrowest street frontage of a lot from
the street in the case of a corner lot or reversed corner lot. A lot may have
more than one front lot line.” (Laguna Beach Mun. Code, § 25.08.022.) And
“‘Lot line, rear’ means a lot line not abutting a street which line is opposite
and most distant from the front lot line. In the case of an irregular,
triangular or gore shaped lot, the rear lot line shall be a line within the lot,
ten feet long, parallel to and at a maximum distance from the front lot line.”
(Ibid.) These definitions are also codified in the zoning title’s “Definitions and
Standards.”
II.
THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL
The owners of the parcel at issue submitted plans to the City to
build a custom home “on a sloping lot” in Laguna Beach in 2017. After
multiple administrative hearings, the City remanded the owners’ application
to address inadequate emergency vehicle access.

one additional matter: Chapter 25.15 of its municipal code. We grant the
Coalition’s request for judicial notice only as to exhibit I, which is the City’s
Land Use Element, and exhibit J, which is the City’s Ordinance No. 1187.
(Evid. Code, § 452, subd. (b).) We deny all other requests. (See Planning &
Conservation League v. Department of Water Resources (2024) 98 Cal.App.5th
726, 774 [denying request “as immaterial”]; Palomar Health v. National
Nurses United (2023) 97 Cal.App.5th 1189, 1199, fn. 5 [denying request
“because the documents are already part of the appellate record”].)

4
The owners submitted revised plans in 2022, which showed the
“Lot Slope” calculated as “32.6%” without explanation. The City’s Design
Review Board approved construction.
Neighbors filed a notice of administrative appeal to the City
Council. (Laguna Beach Mun. Code, § 25.05.070, subd. (B)(2).) They attached
letters asserting the project was inconsistent with the general plan in various
ways, mostly relating to the driveway’s inadequacy as a fire lane; some
expressed general concerns about the hillside. None mentioned Policy 14-B or
provided a slope calculation.
The City issued a “Notice of a Public Hearing” for the
administrative appeal. (Boldface and some capitalization omitted.) It
provided: “You may also communicate comments about the proposed
application and the appeal to members of the City Council,” and that
“[w]ritten correspondence should be delivered to City Hall by noon the day
before the hearing.” (Boldface omitted.)
The day before the hearing, an architect retained by neighbors
submitted a letter raising the slope issue. He contended the project was
inconsistent with Policy 14-B, asserting the “existing natural site has no
slope less than 62% within setbacks, and most of the site has slopes of 80% to
100% (a 45 degree angle).”

5
While the architect did not describe how he calculated slope in
any detail, Exhibit B to the letter provided an illustration:

Exhibit B’s left side identifies eight different slope calculations, ranging
between 62 percent to 100 percent. The right side shows a cross-section of the
home with a line going through it at a 41 degree angle, corresponding to a 91
percent slope.
At the administrative appeal hearing, the City Council
considered the slope issue at length. The first speaker, the City planner,
noted: “A question that came up as we were preparing for this evening was
regarding the overall lot slope for the property.”
He presented a diagram showing “how we calculate the average
lot slope for the property” as “about 36 percent”:

6
He explained: “you can see in the upper left-hand corner there’s a green line
that is depicting what we’re considering the front property line, and then
there is a blue line to the south depicting what we consider the rear property
line. [¶] And essentially the way the code evaluates average lot slope for
properties is we’re taking the midpoint of the front, drawing a line to the
midpoint of the back and that dimension determines the run in the slope
calculation. And so as you can see towards the bottom left, when we calculate
the average slope of the lot it comes out to be about 36 percent. This is
primarily due to the cross slope condition over that line.” (Because we cannot
replicate the drawing in color, we note that the green front property line has
the arrow annotated “Approx. 300’ NG” and the blue rear property line has
the arrow annotated “Approx. 243’ NG.”)
When a councilmember noted the general plan does not address
the average slope, the city planner replied: “You know, we rely on what

7
direction the municipal code gives and to supplement those policies. And our
typical practice and evaluating lot slope is looking at the average since we
have other municipal code requirements that have, you know, requirements
related to slope.” The city attorney added: “Well, I think the question goes to
just what the historical practice or interpretation has been of those
regulations . . . .”
The city planner continued: “But it’s also interpreted in
combination with the municipal code, which is the implementation document
of the general plan. And if it were just 45 percent generally speaking, it’s not
really clear to me how that could be applied because on -- on most properties
you can find pockets or small areas where maybe the slope is greater than 45
percent. We don’t have the means to go through and calculate every portion
of the property to evaluate slope. It’s not clear how the boundaries of that
would be defined.” He clarified: “So it really isn’t intended for the average
slope of the entire property.”
A neighbor spoke next and stated: “Our general plan does not
allow building on slopes of 45 percent or greater. We did take the time to look
at the actual slope and you can see that this -- this site is almost like
climbing El Capitan and Yosemite. It’s averaging anywhere between 80 to
100 percent.” Another neighbor added: “It’s -- that’s a disingenuous
calculation to use an average. It’s like saying you have a half acre lot, and
we’re gonna say the average is 20 but the footprint of the house happens to be
on 60 or 70. But it’s okay because the whole lot is 30.” He stated Policy 14-B
“prohibits construction and grading on slopes greater than 45 percent. Not an
average, the actual footprint of the house.”
The neighbors’ architect discussed the City’s slope calculation: “I
think the distinction of the average site slope versus the slope in -- in various

8
portions of the site. The -- the average site slope is something that planning
department uses and it did follow that definition.” Apparently referring to
Exhibit B, the neighbor’s architect continued: “So you can see it in the section
to the right, the angle that is in the submittal drawings is correct. It’s -- it’s
showing at that location 41 -- 41 degrees, which is like a 91 percent slope
where the building is planned to have foundations dug.”
An attorney (now the Coalition’s counsel) echoed this: “what the
architect is showing is when it comes to the actual footprint. Okay. That
footprint is going to be where -- where the -- the footprint of the home is
gonna be. Those things are way exceeding that and -- and the code here is not
using the word average.”
After several additional speakers, the City Council asked the city
planner again about the slope calculation. One member asked: “Can we once
more quickly just so I’m -- show how -- what the -- the rise over run was for
the -- I’m -- I’m clear of what the definition of the percent slope is. I think I
just -- to show what -- what we’re measuring from the rise over run.” The city
planner answered: “Right. So the -- the rise over run lot slope calculation is
based on how the code defines the -- the lot slope. And utilizing that
definition is how we determine the location of the dashed line. So in order to
determine the -- the rise or the difference in elevation between these two
points, between the front property line and the rear property line, we used
the elevations at those points to determine the rise and -- and then the run is
the overall distance of that line per of the calculation provided here.”
When a councilmember asked how the city planner “decide[d]
to define the rear and the front property line,” the city planner replied: “So
typically with the flag lot configuration, the panhandle portion is discounted
from the overall lot calculations. As you can imagine, if we took the line -- the

9
dashed line all the way out to the terminus of 3rd Avenue, the lot slope would
be much less than 36 percent. So typically we discount the panhandle portion
and that becomes the new -- we -- we call it a false property line and that is
how we determine the front. And then the rear property line is the one that's
opposite and parallel to that line.” He clarified: “these determinations of the
lot lines, the methodologies used to determine the lot slope, this is based on
the municipal codes’ definitions.”
The City denied the appeal four to one. One councilmember
stated: “I’ve spent more hours on this appeal than I’ve seen done on any other
appeal,” yet “I just can’t in a fair way com[e] to the conclusion that -- that --
that the property owners here don’t have the ability to move forward with
this project.” The dissenting councilmember stated: “I don’t think the slope is
measured properly. When I went out there, if I was -- fell down that road, I’d
probably be dead.”
III.
THE WRIT PETITION
The Coalition, alleging it “is an unincorporated umbrella
organization” of Laguna Beach residents and property owners “devoted to the
preservation of the environment,” filed a petition for a writ of mandate. It
claimed “the slope of the Project Site is so steep that the General Plan does
not allow its development.”
At the hearing, the court questioned the City’s slope calculation.
It noted: “You can label any part of the slope or the project ‘the upper’ and
any part as ‘the lower.’ And what it looks like . . . the city has done, the
planner found the most favorable upper point and most favorable lower point
when, in fact, if you just measured the ultimate rise in vertical distance from
the lowest point to the highest point, you get a much different percentage.”

10
Counsel for the City replied that “front property line” is “defined
in the code” and was chosen “because it faces the street.” When the court
later asked the owners’ counsel, “it looks like, depending on where you decide
the front and back is and how you turn the property around, you can almost
always get to a less than 45 percent slope,” counsel responded: “Yes. If the
city was allowed to arbitrarily select a side. But in order to avoid that
arbitrary option, they follow the code. Here, that is the street that faces --
that is the side that faces the street. That is how the code defines the front
property line.”
The trial court allowed supplemental briefing on “the General
Plan metric” for slope calculation because “neither party had mentioned the
General Plan methodology or metric for determining the allowable slope for
building on hillsides” until the Coalition’s reply brief.
In its supplemental brief, the Coalition attached a copy of a
survey commissioned by the owners and attached to the City’s design review
board report. According to the Coalition, it used the notations and scale on
the survey to calculate the vertical distance between the highest and lowest
points on the parcel as 86 feet and the horizontal distance between those
points as 100 feet, for a slope of 86%.
After more supplemental briefing on exhaustion of
administrative remedies, the court granted the petition. It found “City
Council members” were “fairly apprised” of the slope issue because “the issue
of building on land with a slope in excess of 45% was front and center” at the
hearing.
The court further found the project’s slope exceeded 45 percent. It
reasoned: “the City is constrained to use the formula set forth in the General
Plan, which simply mentions ‘the change in vertical distance’ without the

11
word ‘average.’” It rejected the City’s “‘longstanding practice’ of following” the
municipal code’s definition of “slope in percent.” It found “the only proper
record evidence of slope is that the Project would be built on a 91% slope.”

DISCUSSION
I.
THE COALITION LARGELY EXHAUSTED ITS ADMINISTRATIVE REMEDIES
Both the Coalition and the City rely on the CEQA2 standard for
the exhaustion doctrine, which is a “jurisdictional prerequisite” for
challenging an agency’s decision in court. (Mani Brothers Real Estate Group
v. City of Los Angeles (2007) 153 Cal.App.4th 1385, 1394 (Mani Brothers).)
“The ‘exact issue’ must have been presented” when seeking administrative
relief because “the agency ‘“is entitled to learn the contentions of interested
parties before litigation is instituted.”’” (Ibid.)
“However, ‘less specificity is required to preserve an issue for
appeal in an administrative proceeding than in a judicial proceeding.’” (Mani
Brothers, supra, 153 Cal.App.4th at p. 1395.) The basic issue is whether the
City was “fairly apprised” of the concern so that it had “the opportunity to
evaluate and respond to” it. (United Neighborhoods for Los Angeles v. City of
Los Angeles (2023) 93 Cal.App.5th 1074, 1088, 1091 [cleaned up]; accord Save
Our Residential Environment v. City of West Hollywood (1992) 9 Cal.App.4th
1745, 1750.)
Here, the City was “fairly apprised” about the slope issue. The
City planner presented his 36 percent slope calculation near the start of his
presentation at the hearing, noting the issue “came up as we were preparing
for this evening.” The ensuing discussion among city councilmembers, the

2 The acronym refers to the California Environmental Quality

Act. (Pub. Resources Code, § 21000 et seq.)

12
city planner, and the city attorney consumed approximately 10 transcript
pages. Neighbors, their architect, and the Coalition’s counsel-to-be all
discussed slope calculations. The City Council then returned to the topic for
additional discussion. (Cf. Citizens for Responsible Equitable Environmental
Development v. City of San Diego (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 515, 527–528 [issue
not “‘fairly presented’” when it was “buried among thousands of documents”
and not discussed at the hearing].) As the trial court correctly found, the
slope issue was “front and center.”
We find this adequate even though, as the City notes, a
municipal code section limits certain administrative appeals “to the grounds
specifically stated in the notice of appeal.” (Laguna Beach Mun. Code,
§ 25.05.070, subd. (E)(2)(b).) To be sure, the notice of appeal here could have
been more specific. The attached letters raised hillside concerns only
generally, without invoking Policy 14-B or challenging the slope calculation.
But the City Council entertained extensive discussion of slope, with the
councilmembers themselves repeatedly asking questions and seeking
clarification. We fail to see any unfairness to the City in how the slope issue
was raised.3

3 We might come to a different conclusion about the Coalition’s

86% slope calculation, which it submitted with supplemental briefing to the
trial court, as the City did not have any “opportunity to evaluate and respond
to” it during the administrative appeal. (United Neighborhoods, supra, 93
Cal.App.5th at p. 1091 [cleaned up].) But the Coalition mentions the
calculation in only one sentence of its respondent’s brief.

13
II.
THE CITY DID NOT ABUSE ITS DISCRETION BY APPROVING THE PROJECT
BECAUSE ITS SLOPE CALCULATION WAS REASONABLE
The Coalition contends the City’s approval of the project was
inconsistent with Policy 14-B because it rests on an unreasonable and
arbitrary slope calculation.
To be sure, the “‘propriety of virtually any local decision affecting
land use and development depends upon consistency with the applicable
general plan and its elements.’” (Citizens of Goleta Valley v. Board of
Supervisors (1990) 52 Cal.3d 553, 570.)
But a “given project need not be in perfect conformity with each
and every general plan policy. It is enough that the project is compatible with
the plan’s objectives, policies, general land uses, and programs.” (Save
Livermore Downtown v. City of Livermore (2022) 87 Cal.App.5th 1116, 1124
(Save Livermore) [cleaned up].)
“It is the province of elected city officials to examine the specifics
of a proposed project to determine whether it would be in harmony with the
policies stated in the plan. It is, emphatically, not the role of the courts to
micromanage these development decisions. We decide merely whether city
officials considered the applicable policies and the extent to which the
proposed project conforms with those policies, whether the city officials made
appropriate findings on this issue, and whether those findings are supported
by substantial evidence.” (Save Livermore, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 1124
[cleaned up].)
Thus, as we review the City’s action for a prejudicial abuse of
discretion (Save Livermore, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 1125), we “‘defer to a
procedurally proper consistency finding unless no reasonable person could

14
have reached the same conclusion’” (id. at p. 1124; accord Families Unafraid
to Uphold Rural etc. County v. Board of Supervisors (1998) 62 Cal.App.4th
1332, 1338 (Families Unafraid) [county’s determination that project was
“consistent with the Draft General Plan carries a strong presumption of
regularity”]).
Here, the City did not abuse its discretion. It “considered the
applicable polic[y]” (Policy 14-B) and whether the project conformed with it,
made the appropriate finding on that issue (at least implicitly), and that
finding was “‘supported by substantial evidence’”—namely, the City planner’s
36 percent slope calculation. (Save Livermore, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at
p. 1124.) This satisfies the limited nature of our review. (Ibid. [courts
“‘emphatically’” do not “‘micromanage these development decisions’”].)
The general plan’s definition of slope may be mandatory but it is
also incomplete. The plan defines slope as “an inclined ground surface, the
inclination of which is expressed as a ratio of horizontal distance to vertical
distance.” (Laguna Beach General Plan Open Space and Conservation
Elements, § III, p. 63.) But as the City observes, the plan does not specify
“how the City is to select the points between which vertical distance and
horizontal distance are to be measured.” Determining those points is
relatively straightforward in two dimensions, on an x-y graph. But it is less
clear what points to use when measuring a three-dimensional hillside that
may have any number of contours, cross-slopes, and level areas.
With such variations in topography, we cannot say as a matter of
law that the only reasonable approach to determining rise and run is to look

15
for absolute high and low points. No expert so testified.4 And as the City
planner noted, “on most properties you can find pockets or small areas where
maybe the slope is greater than 45 percent.” It hardly seems reasonable to
measure the slope of a level putting green from the bottom of the cup to the
top. Or to measure the slope of otherwise flat desert land from the base of a
boulder to the top.
It is not as though the Coalition has steadfastly maintained there
is only one true slope here. It has offered at least 10 different slope
calculations: the eight slopes ranging from 62 percent to 100 percent
corresponding to various rock outcroppings, the 91 percent slope
corresponding to the height of the home and the depth of its footprint, and
the 86 percent slope corresponding to the high and low points of the parcel.
While the Coalition has vacillated somewhat in its calculations,
the City is perhaps overly rigid in its reliance on the municipal code. When a
councilmember reasonably asked how the City ascertained the front and rear
property lines, the City planner mentioned “discount[ing]” the “panhandle
portion” of a “flag lot configuration” and taking “a false property line.” He
assured the council that “these determinations of the lot lines, the
methodologies used to determine the lot slope, this is based on the municipal
codes’ definitions.” Yet he did not actually work through the municipal code
definitions of front and rear lot lines or explain why applying those
definitions made sense, either as a general approach to calculating slope or in
assessing this particular project. He just said, in essence, “whatever the code
says is right.” It’s little wonder the trial court noted: “‘The Planning and

4 Any number of experts might arguably shed light on how slope

is reasonably measured: surveyors, urban planners, civil engineers,
geologists, or mathematicians. We set no hard-and-fast rules here.

16
Zoning Law does not contemplate that general plans will be amended to
conform to zoning ordinances. The tail does not wag the dog.’”
On the other hand, at the writ petition hearing, counsel for the
City and the owners provided the more commonsensical explanation that the
front property line “faces the street.” Counsel for the owners went on to
explain that applying a consistent definition of front and rear property lines
tends to reduce the kind of result-oriented analysis that concerned the court.
So would, we imagine, the City’s standard procedure for (1) determining rise
by subtracting the average elevation of the rear property line from the
average elevation of the front property line (or vice versa); (2) measuring run
by the average “depth of the lot”; and (3) as Policy 14-B directs, dividing rise
by run and multiplying by 100. The neighbors’ architect agreed “the average
site slope is something that planning department uses and it did follow that
definition.” A consistent approach—any consistent approach—would seem to
benefit property owners, neighbors, and the City.
That this methodology is located in the municipal code (as the
City trumpets) or was adopted to regulate building height (as the Coalition
decries), is immaterial. What matters is this: while we cannot say this is the
only reasonable way to determine rise and run of a slope for hillside
development, we cannot say it is unreasonable either.
The City is entitled to deference in construing its own general
plan. “‘[I]t is the province of elected city officials’” to determine whether a
project “‘would be “in harmony” with the policies stated in the [general] plan
and, “‘emphatically, not the role of the courts to micromanage these
development decisions.’” (Save Livermore, supra, 87 Cal.App.5th at p. 1124.)
The City’s consistency determination “carries a strong presumption of
regularity.” (Families Unafraid, supra, 62 Cal.App.4th at p. 1338.) We should

17
“‘defer to a procedurally proper consistency finding unless no reasonable
person could have reached the same conclusion.’” (Save Livermore, at p.
1124.) We cannot say no reasonable person could agree the slope here,
measured essentially from the street back, is approximately 36 percent.
DISPOSITION
The judgment is reversed. The trial court is directed to vacate its
judgment and enter a new judgment denying the Coalition’s petition for a
writ of mandate. The City shall recover its costs on appeal.

SCOTT, ACTING P. J.

WE CONCUR:

SERVINO, J.

SCHWARM, J.*

*Judge of the Orange County Superior Court, assigned by the Chief Justice
pursuant to article VI, section 6 of the California Constitution.

18





Description * * * The City of Laguna Beach appeals from a judgment entered after the trial court granted a writ of mandate directing it to set aside its approval of a construction project. The court found the project conflicted with the City’s general plan, which prohibits development on slopes of 45 percent or greater. The City raises two issues: (1) petitioner Laguna Beach Coalition for Environmental Protection failed to exhaust its administrativ
Rating
0/5 based on 0 votes.

    Home | About Us | Privacy | Subscribe
    © 2026 Fearnotlaw.com The california lawyer directory

  Copyright © 2026 Result Oriented Marketing, Inc.

attorney
scale