Filed 9/16/26 Vitale v. A&B Investments, Inc. CA1/5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on
opinions not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule
8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or ordered published for
purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION FIVE
ROBYN VITALE,
Plaintiff and Appellant, A170102
v.
A&B INVESTMENTS, INC.,
(Alameda County Super. Ct. No.
Defendant and Respondent. HG20052739)
Robyn Vitale appeals from the trial court’s grant of
summary judgment on his negligence claim against A&B
Investments, Inc. He asserts that the trial court should not have
rejected his claim that, after he was assaulted in the parking lot
of a liquor store owned by A&B, A&B breached its duty to call
911. We affirm.
BACKGROUND
A.
The assault occurred in February 2018, on the evening of
Super Bowl Sunday. A&B’s owner, Ahmad Rasheed, had hired
Vitale to power wash the parking lot of the liquor store. Rasheed
was not present at the store at the time, but a clerk was on duty
that night.
While Vitale was power washing, Flora Gomez and Marcos
Diaz drove into the parking lot. After Vitale attempted to stop
1
them from entering an area he had cordoned off, an altercation
ensued in which Vitale sprayed Gomez and Diaz with the power
hose and Diaz grabbed a broom and hit Vitale with it. Vitale fell
to the ground and others in the parking lot came to his aid. The
incident happened “pretty quickly” and lasted less than a minute.
The police arrived and put Diaz in a police car before
ultimately transporting him to jail. Diaz was later charged with
felony assault and convicted.
According to Vitale, he “suffered serious bodily injuries to
his left arm, shoulder, back, head, neck and lower body,” and he
was “transported to the hospital for medical treat[]ment and
care.”
Rasheed testified about the incident at a deposition in
2023. By that time, over five years after the assault, he was
unable to provide the last name or address of the clerk who was
on duty that night. Rasheed testified that the clerk called him
after the incident and told him that he “went outside and --
because I think some customer came in and told him there’s
something going on outside, there’s a fight going on outside, or
there’s something outside. And so he went out there.” When
asked whether the clerk told him he had called the police,
Rasheed responded: “I think by the time he went out there, I
think somebody already called the Sheriff when he found out
there’s something going on. The Sheriff had already been called.”
B.
Vitale’s negligence complaint alleged that A&B failed in its
duty “to take reasonable steps to secure the business premises
against foreseeable negligent and criminal acts of third parties
that were likely to occur in the absence of precautionary
measures.” A&B did not take “any steps to prevent and halt
assaults on persons legally on the premises such as Plaintiff.” In
addition, A&B “breached its duty as a business owner to Plaintiff
2
when its employee observed the assault on Plaintiff in the
parking lot, and heard Plaintiff’s cries for help, but failed and
refused to call 911 or otherwise attempt to intervene or prevent
further harm.”
A&B’s summary judgment motion argued that Vitale was
unable to establish a cause of action for negligence. A plaintiff
asserting negligence must establish that the defendant held a
duty; the defendant breached that duty; and the defendant’s
breach was the proximate cause of the plaintiff’s injury.
(Vasilenko v. Grace Family Church (2017) 3 Cal.5th 1077, 1083.)
A&B argued that summary judgment was warranted because
Vitale’s evidence of duty and causation was insufficient.
The trial court must grant summary judgment when there
is no disputed issue of material fact and the movant is entitled to
judgment as a matter of law. (See Code Civ. Proc., § 437c, subd.
(c).1) Section 437c, subdivision (p)(2), provides that in moving for
summary judgment, a “defendant . . . has met that party’s burden
of showing that a cause of action has no merit if the party has
shown that one or more elements of the cause of action . . . cannot
be established, or that there is a complete defense to the cause of
action.” Once the defendant has met that burden, the burden
shifts to the plaintiff to produce specific facts raising a triable
issue of material fact as to the cause of action. (See § 437c, subd.
(p)(2); Lyle v. Warner Brothers Television Productions (2006) 38
Cal.4th 264, 274 (Lyle).)
Vitale’s opposition to the summary judgment motion
argued that A&B violated its duty to “prevent” violent harm to
him while he was performing work for them, by failing “to take
safety precautions to prevent an attack” and “fail[ing] to provide
a safe working environment.”
Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil
1
Procedure.
3
In granting the motion, the trial court held that A&B did
not owe Vitale a duty of care. The court reasoned in part that
although the proprietor of a business generally owes invitees a
duty to control the reasonably foreseeable wrongful acts of third
persons, Vitale had failed to raise a triable issue of fact on the
foreseeability of the assault. The only admissible evidence in the
record was that Rasheed was unaware of any violent crime in the
vicinity of the store in the last decade.2 The trial court also
reasoned that based on the undisputed facts, there was “little
relation between [A&B’s] conduct and the injury” and Vitale’s
“injuries resulted from parties unaffiliated with” A&B. In
addition, the trial court noted that although Vitale “suggest[ed]
that the employee failed to call the sheriff even though he was
aware of the altercation[,] . . . the testimony cited by [Vitale]
states that the employee ‘had no idea’ that there was an
altercation ‘because he was inside’ and by the time he went
outside ‘somebody already called the Sheriff.’ ”
DISCUSSION
Vitale contends that the trial court erred in granting
summary judgment because A&B did not negate his allegation
that it breached its duty to help by failing to call 911.3 On our de
2 The trial court rejected a declaration by Vitale’s security
consultant which opined that the liquor store was located in a
high crime area. The court reasoned that the consultant’s
declaration failed to establish the basis of his expert opinion and
relied on hearsay and unauthenticated material. The court also
rejected an underwriting report from A&B’s insurer because it
was unauthenticated hearsay. Vitale does not challenge these
evidentiary rulings on appeal.
3 Vitale’s trial court brief in opposition to summary
judgment did not argue that A&B breached a duty of care when
its employee failed to call 911. His statement of facts did assert,
however, that “[t]he clerk . . . failed to call the sheriff even though
he was aware of an altercation involving a customer and even
4
novo review (Lyle, supra, 38 Cal.4th at p. 274), his contention
lacks merit.
In some circumstances, “a proprietor’s special-relationship-
based duty to its patrons or invitees includes an obligation” to
call 911 or take other minimal measures to summon aid for a
victim of criminal conduct. (Morris v. De La Torre (2005) 36
Cal.4th 260, 277.)
Assuming that A&B generally had such a duty here, we
agree with A&B that there was no triable issue of material fact
that its actions or omissions caused harm to Vitale. The only
evidence in the record regarding the actions of the clerk was
Rasheed’s deposition testimony that by the time the clerk learned
of the incident and went outside to the parking lot on the night of
the assault, someone else had already called the sheriff. Vitale
argues that Rasheed’s testimony about the clerk’s actions is
inadmissible hearsay, but Vitale forfeited that contention by
failing to assert it below, and indeed, he affirmatively submitted
and relied on this testimony as part of his opposition to summary
judgment. (See § 437c, subd. (b)(5) [“Evidentiary objections not
made at the hearing shall be deemed waived.”].)
Vitale contends that Rasheed was “unclear” about whether
law enforcement authorities had been called by the time the clerk
went outside. Although he used the phrase “I think” to preface
some statements, Rasheed testified without caveat that “[t]he
Sheriff had already been called.” Vitale points to no evidence to
the contrary.
To the extent Vitale asserts that a delay in calling the
sheriff compounded his injuries, he has not pointed to any facts
indicating that there was any delay or that he suffered injury as
a result. It is undisputed that the altercation was “pretty
went outside the store when he heard there was a fight going on,”
citing Rasheed’s deposition testimony.
5
quick[]” and lasted about a minute. Vitale testified at his
deposition that once Diaz hit him, bystanders “came to [his]
aid[].” He presented no evidence about how long it took for the
authorities to arrive. Nor did he present any evidence that the
assault continued until the authorities arrived or that any delay
in their arrival otherwise worsened his injuries. Indeed, Vitale’s
reply brief wholly ignores A&B’s argument that there is no
triable issue of material fact on causation.
Vitale also argues that “there [wa]s no evidence of . . .
whether the A&B employee called an ambulance.” Because the
record contains no evidence that the clerk failed to call an
ambulance, however, Vitale cannot raise a triable issue of
material fact that he was harmed based on breach of any duty to
make such a call.
In sum, A&B was entitled to summary judgment because
Vitale is unable to establish his cause of action for negligence
based on failure to call 911. (See § 437c, subds. (c), (p)(2).)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.
BURNS, J.
WE CONCUR:
JACKSON, P. J.
SIMONS, J.
Robyn Vitale v. A&B Investments, Inc. (A170102)
6


