Fear Not Law CA Unpub Decisions

Marriage of Yu and Sun CA6

Filed 9/16/26 Marriage of Yu and Sun CA6
CA Unpub Decisions

Filed 9/16/26 Marriage of Yu and Sun CA6
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions not certified for
publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion has not been certified for publication or
ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA

SIXTH APPELLATE DISTRICT

In re the Marriage of LIJUN YU and H053090
XUSHENG SUN. (Santa Clara County
Super. Ct. No. 22FL003134)

LIJUN YU,

Appellant,

v.

XUSHENG SUN,

Respondent.

Appellant Lijun Yu appeals from a judgment annulling her marriage to respondent
Xusheng Sun under Family Code section 2210, subdivision (d)1 (section 2210(d)) on the
basis of fraud. Yu contends that Sun “freely cohabited” with her “with full knowledge of
the facts constituting the fraud,” and therefore an annulment was improper. (Ibid.)
For reasons that we will explain, we will affirm the judgment.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

A. Yu’s Petition for Dissolution and Sun’s Response Requesting an Annulment
The parties were married in 2018. Yu filed a petition for dissolution of marriage in
September 2022. Sun filed a response requesting that the marriage be annulled based on

1
Unspecified statutory references are to the Family Code unless otherwise indicated.
fraud. In his request for a bifurcated trial, Sun contended that they never had sex, and that
Yu married him only to obtain permanent residency and citizenship in the United States. In
response, Yu agreed to a separate trial on the issue of an annulment but contended that they
“did have sexual intercourse” and denied that she married him only to obtain a green card.

B. Trial
A bifurcated trial was held on the issue of nullity. The evidence at trial included the
following:
The parties met online in September 2016. Sun was 35 years old and a permanent
resident of the United States, having arrived in 2006. He did not have a successful dating
history and was a virgin. Yu was 31 years old and had graduated a few months prior from
an American university. She had an internship and was on a “student visa extension.” They
discovered that they had grown up in the same city, and that they had attended the same
high school and college in China.
The parties started dating in November 2016, and began living together in December
2016. Prior to marriage, Yu complained about issues such as Sun’s “hygiene,” weight, and
not doing enough housework. When Sun sought to have sex prior to marriage, Yu indicated
that they had to be married.
Sun proposed marriage to Yu multiple times. Shortly before she finally accepted,
they discussed her immigration status. Yu asked Sun if he would support her green card
application through marriage. It was Sun’s understanding that marriage-based green cards
were quicker to obtain than employment-based green cards. Sun agreed to help Yu. In the
meantime, Yu obtained a visa through sponsorship by her employer.
Yu and Sun married on August 8, 2018. During the marriage, Yu continued to
complain about Sun’s weight, his “personal hygiene,” the “indoor hygiene,” and his failure
to do housework. She considered leaving the relationship a few times.

2
Sun testified that they never had sexual intercourse, and that they never attempted to
have sexual intercourse. Over the course of the marriage, when Sun asked for sex, Yu
indicated that other issues needed to be resolved first. For example, Sun was depressed for a
period of time, he was out from work for approximately two and a half months due to a
health issue, he was facing the potential loss of his job, and he developed a spine issue that
affected his ability to walk and drive. Yu told Sun to focus on these other matters, not sex.
She also told him to lose weight. Sun tried to work on the biggest issues that Yu indicated
would prevent them from having sex. He sought medical treatment for his depression and
other health issues, and he found a new job. However, each time that Sun lost weight, Yu
would tell him that he needed to lose more.
Sun testified regarding sex that Yu would “never say directly no. She just always
reschedule. You have this new issue last time I didn’t have. You fix that issue most likely,
but you have new issue you have to work on. It’s not that difficult.” Sun further testified, “I
think all of the problems are going to be solved. I got a problem one after another, but I
never give up. I keep working on that. When I finish getting better with one issue, then,
couple months later, there’s another issue, but I never stopped.” Sun testified that Yu never
told him that they would never have sex. Further, according to Sun, they discussed having
children.
When asked why he stayed, Sun testified that Yu was “the most approachable one
because” they had a “lot of things in common.” He further explained it was “still much
easier than if I start from scratch . . . .” Sun testified that he thought Yu was “sincere” and
that sex would happen. She was “very talented,” and he was “attracted to her.” Sun also
testified, “I love her a lot.”
According to Sun, Yu asked him to apply for citizenship because it might make the
process faster for her. Sun later applied for and became a United States citizen in June
2021. The next month, Yu obtained her green card. In November 2021, Sun confronted Yu
about a “ ‘green card marriage.’ ” She denied it.

3
In June 2022, Yu moved out suddenly. Even after she moved out however, she
indicated that she might come back if Sun lost weight.
Sun attempted to get Yu back, including by trying to lose weight. He also contacted
Yu’s new landlord. Sun testified that he was not sure “if it was another fraud,” and he
wanted to know whether she was dating someone else. If so, he would quit trying to lose
weight.
In September 2022, three months after Yu moved out, Sun messaged her, “What
should I do for the rest of my life if I let go of you . . . ?” Sun testified that he thought Yu
was “least likel[y] to defraud [him]” because they were from the same city and same school.
Sun testified that the next day, on September 8, 2022, Yu told him that she would never
have sexual intercourse unless she was deeply in love because she could get pregnant and
accidentally die from a certain pregnancy related condition. At trial, the court found that
Sun “became animated in his testimony” at this point, and he stated that “she should tell me
before she married me.” Instead, during the marriage, she had indicated to him that if he did
“this” or “that,” then they would have sexual intercourse. By the time he learned from Yu
in the fall of 2022 that there was no hope for the relationship, he had lost approximately
40 pounds.
Sun testified about feeling guilty to his parents for not having a child. He was their
only child.
At trial, when Yu was asked whether she found Sun attractive, she testified, “I don’t
find anyone . . . physically attractive.” Her initial impression of him was that he was self-
centered, impolite, overweight, and wearing unclean clothes.
Yu testified that she loved Sun when they married, that she intended to have a sexual
relationship with him, and that she did not marry him for a green card. According to Yu, it
was Sun’s suggestion for her to pursue a green card with a family sponsor.

4
Yu testified that they were “intimate” “very often.” According to Yu, they physically
attempted sexual intercourse a few times but were unsuccessful. She testified that she never
refused to have sex with him. Yu denied that they discussed having children.
At the close of evidence, Sun contended that Yu committed fraud based on her
failure to consummate the marriage. He argued that she repeatedly rejected him every time,
giving various excuses. Sun contended that whether he was naïve or desperate, he persisted
in the marriage believing that they were eventually going to have sex, even trying to lose
weight after she left him. According to Sun, he was unaware of Yu’s secret intention to
never have sex with him until the very end after she had already left him.
Yu contended, among other arguments, that Sun “learned of the fraud on their
wedding night when she refused to have sex, because that was what she promised.”
According to Yu, Sun for nearly four years in the marriage “freely cohabitated with her after
knowing that allegedly she wasn’t going to have sex with him.” Because Sun “freely
continued to cohabit” with her, Yu contended that he was not legally entitled to an
annulment.

C. Trial Court’s Order and Judgment
In a written order, the trial court first described the nature of the parties’ relationship.
The court found that Sun’s testimony indicated that “he was genuinely attracted to [Yu],
grateful for their shared background – same schools, same hometown – and other attributes
he was able to describe. [He] met [her] after many years of unsuccessful searching for a
partner.” Further, in a September 2022 message after Yu had moved out, Sun asked her,
“What should I do for the rest of my life if I let go of you . . . ?”
In “stark contrast” to Sun’s testimony, the trial court found a “curious absence of any
information to explain why [Yu] married [Sun] if not for immigration purposes.” The court
found that Yu’s complaints about Sun, “primarily if not exclusively his weight,
housekeeping, and reported anger issues,” were matters “well known to her prior to the date

5
of marriage” and in fact known “from the very beginning of the relationship” or “early on in
their cohabitation.” The court explained, “This was not a case where [Sun] presented one
way prior to marriage and differently thereafter. And it does not appear that [Yu’s] attitude
towards [Sun] changed over time. It was negative from the start.” It also appeared that Yu
“did not plan to remain in an enduring marriage” because, among other reasons, she
“expressed fear of getting pregnant as a reason for not engaging in sexual intercourse.”
Regarding fraud, the trial court found that Sun married Yu “believing that the parties
would have a regular sexual relationship that could lead to children.” In contrast, Yu “had
no intent to have a regular sexual relationship with [him] and never did have one. This was
a deception that went to the heart of the marital relationship. Moreover, the deception
continued throughout the marriage and kept [Sun] from fully realizing it until after the
parties separated. It appears from [Sun’s] testimony that he continued to believe that if he
complied with [Yu’s] demands a sexual relationship was possible, even after [she] moved
out of the marital home.”
The trial court implicitly found Sun credible and Yu not credible. The court
explained that Sun’s “testimony was precise, consistent and at times bracingly candid.”
Regarding testimony about whether the parties had sex, the court stated, “[Sun] described
regular efforts seeking sex, all rebuffed by [Yu] who would instead encourage him to focus
on a never-ending list of issues. [Sun] testified he was sad when his father died but he got
better, he lost his job but got a better one, he had a spine issue, but he took pills and
exercised and got better. [Sun] said, ‘I never give up.’ But [Sun] noted[,] ‘I get better on
one issue but a couple of months later there’s another issue. It never stopped.’ . . . [Sun]
described his various efforts through the years to touch [Yu] while they were lying in bed,
and having his efforts rebuffed. When asked why he stayed, he provided a compelling,
believable response. He was attracted to [Yu] and believed her when she indicated that sex
was possible if only he lost weight, helped more around the house, etc. The most poignant
evidence of [Sun’s] belief that sex with [Yu] was attainable was his explanation for trying to

6
find out from [Yu’s] landlord if she was seeing anyone. Because if she was seeing someone
else, . . . he would not try to lose weight anymore.” The court found that “[i]n contrast,”
Yu’s various statements over the course of the proceedings, including in discovery
responses and at trial, about whether the pair had sex “cannot be reconciled.”
The trial court ultimately found by clear and convincing evidence that Yu “entered
into the marriage without any intent to engage in a regular or enduring marital relationship.
[She] deceived [Sun] who genuinely loved [her] and expected a relationship that could
result in the birth of children. [Yu’s] deception went to the heart of the marital relationship.
The motive appears to have been to secure a more desirable immigration status. That [Sun]
would not have entered into the relationship with [Yu] had he known they would never have
sex is underscored by his testimony about the obligation he felt to his parents as their only
child.” The court granted a judgment of annulment based on fraud.

II. DISCUSSION
Yu contends that the trial court erred in annulling the marriage because Sun “freely
and willfully cohabitated” with her for several years. She argues that it is “undisputed that
[she] married [him] for immigration purposes” and “undisputed that [they] did not have sex”
in their years-long relationship. Yu contends that Sun “knew that [she] was marrying him
for immigration purposes” and knew “that she did not like his personality and his body.”
According to Yu, Sun chose to stay in the relationship because it was comfortable.

A. General Legal Principles Regarding an Annulment Based on Fraud
Section 2210 provides that a “marriage is voidable and may be adjudged a nullity
if . . . at the time of the marriage” the “consent of either party was obtained by fraud, unless
the party whose consent was obtained by fraud afterwards, with full knowledge of the facts
constituting the fraud, freely cohabited with the other as his or her spouse.” (Id., subd. (d).)2

2
California law has authorized an annulment on this ground for more than 100 years.
(See, e.g., In re Estate of Gregorson (1911) 160 Cal. 21, 25 [quoting a predecessor statute,
former Civ. Code § 82, which provided for an annulment if “ ‘the consent of either party

7
“ ‘A marriage may be annulled for fraud only in an extreme case where the particular fraud
goes to the very essence of the marriage relation. [Citation.]’ ” (In re Marriage of
Goodwin-Mitchell & Mitchell (2019) 40 Cal.App.5th 232, 238 (Mitchell).) The “paradigm
example” is “a spouse who ‘harbors a secret intention at the time of the marriage not to
engage in sexual relations with [the other spouse]. [Citations.]’ [Citations.]”
(In re Marriage of Meagher & Maleki (2005) 131 Cal.App.4th 1, 7.) A “concealed intent to
marry solely to obtain favorable immigration status will also support annulment.
[Citation.]” (Mitchell, supra, at p. 238; see In re Marriage of Liu (1987) 197 Cal.App.3d
143, 156 [affirming judgment of annulment where the wife “entered the marriage to obtain a
green card, and did not intend to engage in sexual relations” with the husband]; see id. at
p. 155.) “Because public policy strongly favors marriage, the fraud must be shown by clear
and convincing evidence. [Citation.]” (Mitchell, supra, at p. 238.)
As we have set forth above, a marriage may be annulled for fraud “unless the party
whose consent was obtained by fraud afterwards, with full knowledge of the facts
constituting the fraud, freely cohabited with the other as his or her spouse.” (§ 2210(d).)
The California Supreme Court has explained that “[t]he language used in the statute was
designed to declare what conduct on the part of the injured party should conclusively
establish a waiver by him of the fraud, in so far as any action for annulment was concerned.
If, with full knowledge of the facts, he freely assumed the rights of marriage, thus affirming
the relation notwithstanding the fraud, he must be held to have waived the fraud and is
barred from any action for annulment.” (Millar v. Millar (1917) 175 Cal. 797, 806.)

was obtained by fraud, unless such party afterwards, with full knowledge of the facts
constituting the fraud, freely cohabited with the other as husband or wife’ ”]; see also In re
Marriage of Rabie (1974) 40 Cal.App.3d 917, 919, fn. 1 (Rabie) [quoting the most recent
predecessor statute, former Civ. Code § 4425, subd. (d), which authorized an annulment if
“[t]he consent of either party was obtained by fraud, unless such party afterwards, with full
knowledge of the facts constituting the fraud, freely cohabited with the other as husband and
wife”].)

8
For example, in Mitchell, supra, 40 Cal.App.5th 232, the appellate court determined
that the wife was not entitled to a judgment of nullity because she “continued to cohabit
long after [she] discovered [her husband’s] infidelity.” (Id. at p. 239.) Specifically, they
“continued to live together and to have sexual relations for another eight months” until the
wife asked the husband to move out. (Ibid.; see also id. at p. 235.)
However, the mere “[s]uspicion, or a belief founded upon inconclusive
circumstances, is not the ‘full knowledge of the facts constituting the fraud’ ” that would
constitute a waiver and preclude an annulment. (Schaub v. Schaub (1945)
71 Cal.App.2d 467, 480 (Schaub).) For example, in Schaub, the husband “believed . . . his
wife was carrying on an illicit relationship” with another man based on reports from a
detective about the pair “associating with” each other. (Id. at p. 480.) The husband
continued to live with his wife for several more months “while . . . making further
investigations.” (Ibid.) The appellate court determined that the husband’s earlier belief
about an illicit relationship “was founded upon suspicion and not upon knowledge of the
facts. Neither [the husband] nor the detectives [who he hired] had any knowledge of the
character of the relationship until they . . . found [the wife] and [her companion] together” in
bed. (Ibid.; see id. at pp. 472-473.)

B. Standard of Review
In reviewing a trial court’s grant of an annulment based on fraud, if the facts are
undisputed, the “application of section 2210 to those facts” has been treated as “a pure
question of law subject to de novo review. [Citation.]” (Mitchell, supra, 40 Cal.App.5th at
p. 239.) On the other hand, if the facts are disputed, the substantial evidence standard of
review applies. (See id. at pp. 238-239.) Under the substantial evidence standard, “ ‘[w]hen
a trial court’s factual determination is attacked on the ground that there is no substantial
evidence to sustain it, the power of an appellate court begins and ends with the
determination as to whether, on the entire record, there is substantial evidence, contradicted

9
or uncontradicted, which will support the determination, and when two or more inferences
can reasonably be deduced from the facts, a reviewing court is without power to substitute
its deductions for those of the trial court.’ ” (Ibid.; see Conservatorship of O.B. (2020)
9 Cal.5th 989, 1011-1012 [describing substantial evidence standard of review when the
burden of proof in the trial court requires clear and convincing evidence].) “ ‘We may not
reweigh the evidence or determine credibility. [Citation.]’ [Citation.] ‘Credibility is a
matter within the trial court’s discretion,’ and the reviewing court must defer to the trial
court’s findings on credibility issues. [Citation.]” (Niko v. Foreman (2006) 144
Cal.App.4th 344, 365 (Niko).)
However, regarding the specific issue of when a party has “full knowledge” of the
fraud such that freely cohabiting with the other party thereafter would preclude an
annulment (§ 2210(d)), some courts have indicated that an abuse of discretion standard
applies. (See, e.g., Handley v. Handley (1960) 179 Cal.App.2d 742, 750 (Handley)
[explaining that “the question of when the plaintiff has ‘full knowledge’ ” is a “matter [that]
rests within the sound discretion of the trial court”]; Rabie, supra, 40 Cal.App.3d at p. 923
[stating that “the trial court has discretion to decide when knowledge was obtained” for
purposes of barring an annulment].) Under the abuse of discretion standard, a trial court’s
“application of the law to the facts is reversible only if arbitrary and capricious.”
(Haraguchi v. Superior Court (2008) 43 Cal.4th 706, 712, fn. omitted (Haraguchi).)
In this case, de novo review is not appropriate. The disputed issues at trial included
(1) whether the parties had sex during the marriage, (2) whether Yu intended to have a
regular sexual relationship with Sun during the marriage, (3) whether Yu married Sun for
immigration purposes, and (4) whether Sun freely cohabited with Yu with full knowledge of
a fraud.
Beyond determining that de novo review does not apply, we need not resolve in this
case whether the proper standard of review is substantial evidence or abuse of discretion.
Even under the abuse of discretion standard, a “trial court’s findings of fact are reviewed for

10
substantial evidence.” (Haraguchi, supra, 43 Cal.4th at p. 711, fn. omitted.) Further,
regardless of which standard we apply – substantial evidence or abuse of discretion – we
reach the same disposition in this case.

C. Analysis
Although disputed by Yu in the trial court, on appeal she now contends it is
undisputed: (1) that she did not have sex with Sun, (2) that she “did not have an intention to
have a long-lasting marital relationship with [him] that would involve sex,” and (3) that she
“married [him] for a green card.” Yu further argues that Sun “knew that [she] was marrying
him for immigration purposes” and knew “that she did not like his personality and his
body.” However, he chose to stay in the relationship because it was comfortable. Yu
contends that because Sun freely and voluntarily lived with her despite knowing this
information, he was not legally entitled to an annulment.
The trial court found that Sun married Yu “believing that the parties would have a
regular sexual relationship that could lead to children.” The court determined that Yu’s
deception in this regard “continued throughout the marriage and kept [Sun] from fully
realizing it until after the parties separated.” Specifically, Sun “continued to believe that if
he complied with [Yu’s] demands a sexual relationship was possible, even after [she] moved
out of the marital home.”
We determine that substantial evidence supports the trial court’s factual findings and
that the court did not abuse its discretion in determining that Sun did not freely cohabit with
Yu with knowledge of the fraud. The record reflects that Sun did not have “full knowledge
of the facts constituting the fraud” about sex until the fall of 2022, which was after the pair
stopped living together. (§ 2210(d).) Sun testified that prior to that time, Yu “never . . .
directly” said “no” when he asked for sex, and she never indicated that they would never
have sex. Instead, she indicated that they would do it later, and that other issues needed to
be resolved first. Sun testified that he thought Yu was “sincere” and that sex would happen.

11
Further, he thought she was “least likel[y] to defraud [him]” because they were from the
same city and school. Consequently, Sun “never g[a]ve up.”
It was not until September 2022, that Yu told Sun that she would “never have sexual
intercourse with [him]” if she was not “deeply in love.” The trial court found that Sun
“became animated in his testimony” at this point and stated that “she should tell me before
she married me.” The court found Sun credible regarding his explanation for why he stayed
in the marriage. The court explained, “When asked why he stayed, he provided a
compelling, believable response. He was attracted to [Yu] and believed her when she
indicated that sex was possible if only he lost weight, helped more around the house, etc.
The most poignant evidence of [Sun’s] belief that sex with [Yu] was attainable was his
explanation for trying to find out from [her] landlord if she was seeing anyone. Because if
she was seeing someone else, . . . he would not try to lose weight anymore.”
On appeal, we must defer to the trial court’s credibility findings, and we may not
reweigh the evidence. (Niko, supra, 144 Cal.App.4th at p. 365.) Substantial evidence
supports the court’s implicit determination that Sun did not “freely cohabit[]” with Yu after
obtaining “full knowledge of the facts constituting the fraud,” that is, full knowledge that Yu
had no intent to have a regular sexual relationship with him. (§ 2210(d); see Mitchell,
supra, 40 Cal.App.5th at pp. 238-239.) On this record, no abuse of discretion has been
shown. (See Handley, supra, 179 Cal.App.2d at p. 750; Rabie, supra, 40 Cal.App.3d at
p. 923.)
Yu contends that Sun, “despite being led on about sex, and despite knowing that one
of the reasons [she was] marrying him” was for immigration reasons, “freely cohabitated
with [her] in a marital relationship.” She argues that he continued living her because she
was “ ‘the most approachable one,’ ” the relationship was comfortable, and he was
“ ‘pragmatic’ ” with the “ ‘most important’ ” issue to him being “ ‘to get a wife.’ ”
We are not persuaded by Yu’s contentions. First, as we have just explained, there is
substantial evidence and the trial court did not abuse its discretion in finding that Sun did

12
not have “full knowledge” (§ 2210(d)) of Yu’s deception until after she moved out.
Although Sun knew prior to Yu moving out that the parties were not having sex, he was not
fully aware of her deception as to the reason why. Specifically, he did not have “full
knowledge of the facts” that she had no intent to have a regular sexual relationship with
him. (Ibid.)
Yu contends that Mitchell, supra, 40 Cal.App.5th 232 is “on point,” but we find that
case distinguishable. In Mitchell, the wife sought an annulment from her husband, who
obtained a visa to the United States after the pair married. (Id. at p. 234.) Within a year or
less, the husband “ ‘engaged in two relationships with women external to his marriage.’ ”
(Id. at p. 237.) The appellate court determined that “a fraudulent intent to stray from the
marital bed may be sufficient for annulment if the offending spouse held that intent at the
time he or she entered into the marriage,” and that a “concealed intent to marry solely to
obtain favorable immigration status will also support annulment. [Citations.]” (Id. at
p. 238.) The appellate court determined however, that the wife was not entitled to an
annulment because the couple “continued to live together and . . . have sexual relations for
another eight months” after the wife discovered the husband’s two other relationships. (Id.
at p. 239.) In contrast, in the present case, although Sun was aware that Yu was not having
sex with him during the marriage, there is no evidence that he knew that she had no intent to
have a regular sexual relationship. (See Schaub, supra, 71 Cal.App.2d at p. 480 [explaining
that a “mere “[s]uspicion, or a belief founded upon inconclusive circumstances,” does not
meet the standard of “full knowledge” under § 2210(d)].)
Second, we are not persuaded by Yu’s contention that Sun was not entitled to an
annulment because he knew that one of the reasons she married him was for immigration
reasons. The trial court’s conclusion that Sun lacked “full knowledge of the facts
constituting the fraud” (§ 2210(d)) pertained to his lack of full knowledge about Yu’s
deception regarding a sexual relationship, not regarding immigration. To the extent the
court’s written order addressed immigration, the court simply observed that Yu’s “motive”

13
for entering into the marriage “appears to have been to secure a more desirable immigration
status.” Consequently, Yu’s argument that Sun knew about her desire to get a green card
through marriage does not invalidate the factual or legal basis for the court’s grant of an
annulment, which was based on Yu’s deception regarding a regular sexual relationship.
Third, we are not persuaded by Yu’s reliance on certain portions of Sun’s testimony
to support her contention that he “accepted the relationship with [her] was devoid of any
physical intimacy,” and that therefore the trial court erred in annulling the marriage.
For example, Sun was asked generally whether he was “trying to meet another
virgin” or whether it mattered to him. Sun responded, “I am pragmatic. I think the most
important is to get a wife. I never expect anyone of the 20 people was to be a virgin . . . .”
This testimony by Sun does not establish that he “accepted” a relationship with Yu devoid
of any physical intimacy.
Sun was also asked why he did not leave the marriage after nearly four years of no
sex. He testified that there were two reasons. First, Yu never directly said no to him.
Second, he testified that he never had sex, and “she was still the most approachable one
because we have a lot of things in common. She have very unique identity. We attended
the same high school, same university, same college. We all been here for a while. We live
together. We like to eat the same things. This is still much easier than I start from scratch,
especially in the case that I have spine issue. I could not date with activities. There’s
pandemic outside, and I couldn’t even get out. [¶] From hindsight, I was extremely stupid,
but I still found that she was sincere. She promised, like, you fix two problem there. I am
the person who want to fix that problem even more than her, because that’s my problem.”
Nothing in these portions of the testimony by Sun suggests that he continued to live with Yu
“with full knowledge of the facts constituting the fraud,” that is, her lack of intent to have a
regular sexual relationship with him. (§ 2210(d).)
Lastly, we are not persuaded by Yu’s contention that Sun knowingly and freely
resided with her based on them living together for two years before marriage and

14
approximately four years while married. The fact that the parties resided together for
several years does not preclude an annulment. (See Handley, supra, 179 Cal.App.2d at
pp. 744, 750 [finding there was substantial evidence and no abuse of discretion in the grant
of an annulment although the parties had been married for more than six years].)
In sum, substantial evidence supports the trial court’s finding, and no abuse of
discretion has been shown regarding the court’s determination, that Sun did not know until
after the parties separated that Yu had no intent to have a regular sexual relationship. Yu
thus fails to establish that Sun “freely cohabited” with her “with full knowledge of the facts
constituting the fraud.” (§ 2210(d).) Accordingly, we conclude that the trial court did not
err in granting an annulment.

III. DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed.

15
_______________________________
Greenwood, P. J.

WE CONCUR:

___________________________________________
Danner, J.

______________________________________
Bromberg, J.

H053090 Yu v. Sun

← Back to CA Unpub Decisions · Knowledge Base
Lean view · served in 1 ms · full site view