Filed 11/10/26 Jackson v. Estate of Perry CA5
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN THE OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
FIFTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
FRED JAY JACKSON,
F089745
Plaintiff and Appellant,
(Super. Ct. No. BCV-21-101400)
v.
ESTATE OF JONATHAN ROBERT PERRY,
M.D., OPINION
Defendant and Respondent.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of Kern County. Gregory A.
Pulskamp, Judge.
Fred Jay Jackson, in pro. per., for Plaintiff and Appellant.
Cole Pedroza, Kenneth R. Pedroza, Amy E. Rankin; Lebeau Thelen, Dennis R.
Thelen and Gary Logan, for Defendant and Respondent.
-ooOoo-
State prison inmate Fred Jay Jackson is the plaintiff and appellant in this medical
malpractice case. Defendant Dr. Jonathan Robert Perry passed away during the pendency
of the action and was replaced by his estate. The Estate of Jonathan Robert Perry, M.D.
(Dr. Perry’s estate or the estate) is the respondent on appeal. The Kern County Superior
Court granted summary judgment to the estate and entered judgment in its favor.
Jackson appealed. He contends the trial court, in ruling on the estate’s summary
judgment motion, should have excluded the declaration of the estate’s medical expert.
Jackson further contends the court abused its discretion in denying his motion for a court-
appointed expert. In addition, Jackson contends his constitutional rights were violated
because he was not present at the hearing on the estate’s summary judgment motion.
Finally, he argues the estate and its attorney have unclean hands and that the unclean
hands doctrine precludes granting of the estate’s summary judgment motion.
Jackson has not established reversible error. We therefore affirm the judgment.
FACTS
On October 3, 2020, Jackson presented to the emergency department at Adventist
Health Tehachapi Valley Hospital (AHTV) with complaints of pain in his left eye and left
shoulder, following an assault at the prison where he was incarcerated. 1 The doctor who
treated him ordered x-rays of his left shoulder. Dr. Perry, a radiologist, read the x-rays
and determined there was “[n]o fracture or malalignment.” Jackson was discharged the
same day, with instructions to ice his left shoulder and follow up with his primary care
doctor within one to two days.
On October 23, 2020, Jackson returned to AHTV with complaints of continuing
pain in his left shoulder. X-rays were ordered; Dr. Perry read the x-rays. This time,
Dr. Perry determined the x-rays reflected a posterior dislocation of the left shoulder.
Jackson was discharged the same day, with instructions to follow up with an orthopedic
specialist within one to two days.
On October 30, 2020, Jackson presented to the office of Dr. Jose Bosque, an
orthopedist with Adventist Health Physicians Network. Five images of Jackson’s left
1 Jackson is incarcerated at California Correctional Institution in Tehachapi.
2.
shoulder were taken that day; the images showed posterior dislocation of the left shoulder
with a reverse Hill-Sachs deformity. Dr. Bosque recommended that Jackson go to the
emergency department for shoulder reduction. 2
On November 20, 2020, approximately seven weeks after he first came to the
emergency department complaining of shoulder pain, Jackson returned to Dr. Bosque’s
office. Dr. Bosque noted that Jackson’s left shoulder had been reduced, and further
procedures were not immediately necessary. Rather, Dr. Bosque recommended a period
of conservative management on a trial basis, with potential surgical intervention to follow
should Jackson continue to experience instability in his left shoulder.
On March 9, 2021, Dr. Bosque performed surgery on Jackson for left shoulder
posterior instability.
PROCEDURAL HISTORY
On June 16, 2021, Jackson filed a complaint initiating the instant action. He
named as defendants AHTV and a number of its emergency department physicians,
specifically, Dr. Perry, Dr. Steven Kushel, and Dr. Richard Leach. The complaint alleged
the defendants acted negligently with respect to Jackson’s October 3, 2020, visit to
AHTV’s emergency department, in that they had concluded his shoulder was not
fractured or dislocated and that no treatment was necessary.
2 Jackson maintains that during his visit to Dr. Bosque’s office on October 30,
2020, he did not directly see or talk to Dr. Bosque. Medical records from Jackson’s
October 30, 2020, visit show Dr. Bosque reviewed the newly-taken images of Jackson’s
left shoulder; diagnosed a “[d]islocation of shoulder, posterior, left, closed”; and
recommended that Jackson go to the emergency department for “shoulder reduction.”
Dr. James Cusator, who was evidently associated with Dr. Bosque’s office, also noted in
the October 30, 2020, medical records that five images were obtained of Jackson’s left
shoulder. Dr. Cusator further noted: “There is posterior dislocation of the humeral head
in relationship to the glenoid. There is a reverse Hill-Sachs deformity. The
acromioclavicular joint is anatomically aligned.”
3.
On September 3, 2024, Jackson filed a second amended complaint (SAC), the
operative complaint in this matter. For present purposes, the parties agreed the SAC
contained a single cause of action for medical negligence encompassing various
theories. 3 By this time, Dr. Perry had passed away and his estate had become a defendant
in his place. Among other things, the SAC alleged that Dr. Kushel misread Jackson’s x-
rays on October 3, 2020, and that Dr. Perry signed off on this “misdiagnosis.”
On November 19, 2024, Dr. Perry’s estate filed a motion for summary judgment,
on the stated basis that there was no triable issue of material fact with respect to
Jackson’s claim of medical negligence by Dr. Perry. In support of the motion,
Dr. Perry’s estate adduced a declaration by a board-certified orthopedic surgeon,
Dr. Michael Klassen. Dr. Klassen opined: “The totality of the circumstances in this case
shows there is no causation of any continuing injury from [Dr. Perry’s assessment of] the
October 3, 2020 x-rays.” Dr. Klassen concluded: “In summary, I believe there is no
indication from the items I have reviewed to suggest there was anything [Dr. Perry] did
or did not do that negligently increased the risk for development of future problems with
the left shoulder of Mr. Jackson.” Jackson filed an opposition to the summary judgment
motion.
On February 14, 2025, the trial court heard the motion for summary judgment
brought by Dr. Perry’s estate; Jackson did not appear at the hearing. The court
determined Jackson had “not demonstrated the existence of a triable issue of fact with
competent, admissible evidence,” and granted the motion for summary judgment. The
court’s written order was filed on March 3, 2025; the order provided that “judgment is
entered in favor of Defendant, the Estate of Jonathan Robert Perry, M.D., Deceased[.]”
3 Defendants had filed demurrers and motions to strike to Jackson’s sequential
complaints, the details of which are not fully reflected in the record.
4.
This appeal followed. 4
DISCUSSION
I. Trial Court Properly Considered Declaration of Dr. Michael Klassen
Dr. Perry’s estate submitted an expert declaration from Dr. Michael Klassen in
support of its motion for summary judgment. Jackson argues the trial court should have
excluded Dr. Klassen’s declaration. He contends that defense counsel had improperly
manipulated the medical records that were provided to Dr. Klassen in a deliberate ploy to
mislead him. He contends defense counsel had fraudulently concealed and/or altered
certain relevant medical records in a bid to obtain a favorable opinion on the issue of
causation. We conclude Jackson has not shown the trial court erred in considering
Dr. Klassen’s opinions.
A. Applicable Law
“Generally, ‘negligence’ is the failure to exercise the care a reasonable person
would exercise under the circumstances. [Citation.] Medical negligence is one type of
negligence, to which general negligence principles apply.” (Massey v. Mercy Medical
Center Redding (2009) 180 Cal.App.4th 690, 694.) “The elements of a medical
malpractice claim are ‘ “ ‘(1) the duty of the professional to use such skill, prudence, and
diligence as other members of his profession commonly possess and exercise; (2) a
breach of that duty; (3) a proximate causal connection between the negligent conduct and
the resulting injury; and (4) actual loss or damage resulting from the professional’s
negligence.’ ” ’ ” (Avivi v. Centro Medico Urgente Medical Center (2008)
159 Cal.App.4th 463, 468, fn. 2 (Avivi).)
“Both the standard of care and [a defendant’s] breach must normally be
established by expert testimony in a medical malpractice case.” (Avivi, supra,
4 Jackson has been determined by the courts to be a vexatious litigant and is
subject to a prefiling order entered against him under Code of Civil Procedure
section 391.7. This court granted Jackson’s request to file the instant appeal.
5.
159 Cal.App.4th at p. 467.) In addition, “ ‘[c]ausation must be proven within a
reasonable medical probability based upon competent expert testimony.’ ” (Dumas v.
Cooney (1991) 235 Cal.App.3d 1593, 1603; see Haning, et al., Cal. Practice Guide:
Personal Injury (The Rutter Group 2022) ¶ 2:2405 [“Causation is a question of
reasonable probability; ‘legal cause’ need not be proved with certainty, but mere
possibility is insufficient to establish a prima facie case. Thus, the issue is whether it is
more likely than not that plaintiff’s injury was a result of defendant’s act or omission.”];
see also Sarti v. Salt Creek Ltd. (2008) 167 Cal.App.4th 1187, 1210 [“California law on
causation is ‘substantial factor.’ ”]; CACI, No. 400.)
Thus, “ ‘[w]henever the plaintiff claims negligence in the medical context, the
plaintiff must present evidence from an expert that the defendant breached his or her duty
to the plaintiff and that the breach caused the injury to the plaintiff.’ ” (Sanchez v. Kern
Emergency Medical Transportation Corp. (2017) 8 Cal.App.5th 146, 153; accord
Powell v. Kleinman (2007) 151 Cal.App.4th 112, 123.)
Evidence Code section 720, subdivision (a) provides: “A person is qualified to
testify as an expert if he has special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education
sufficient to qualify him as an expert on the subject to which his testimony relates.
Against the objection of a party, such special knowledge, skill, experience, training, or
education must be shown before the witness may testify as an expert.” However, “[a]n
expert’s opinion, even if uncontradicted, may be rejected if the reasons given for it are
unsound.” (Kelley v. Trunk (1998) 66 Cal.App.4th 519, 523.)
As for summary judgment, it is properly granted when no triable issue exists as to
any material fact and the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter of law. (Code
Civ. Proc., 5 § 437c, subd. (c).) A defendant moving for summary judgment has the
burden of establishing that “one or more elements of the cause of action cannot be
5 Undesignated statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.
6.
established[.]” (Hanson v. Grode (1999) 76 Cal.App.4th 601, 603-604; § 437c,
subd. (p)(2).) “[G]enerally, the party moving for summary judgment bears an initial
burden of production to make a prima facie showing of the nonexistence of any triable
issue of material fact; if he carries his burden of production, he causes a shift, and the
opposing party is then subjected to a burden of production of [its] own to make a prima
facie showing of the existence of a triable issue of material fact.” (Aguilar v. Atlantic
Richfield Co. (2001) 25 Cal.4th 826, 850; § 437c, subd. (p)(2).)
On appeal, we apply the same analysis. (Torres v. Reardon (1992) 3 Cal.App.4th
831, 836.) “We review the trial court’s decision de novo, considering all of the evidence
the parties offered in connection with the motion (except that which the court properly
excluded) and the uncontradicted inferences the evidence reasonably supports.”
(Merrill v. Navegar, Inc. (2001) 26 Cal.4th 465, 476.)
B. Background
In support of its motion for summary judgment, Dr. Perry’s estate provided
declarations from its attorney, Gary Logan (attorney Logan or defense counsel), and from
its expert witness, Dr. Klassen. Attorney Logan stated in his declaration that true and
correct copies of Jackson’s medical records from AHTV and from “Adventist Health
Physicians Network, Jose Bosque, M.D.” were attached to his declaration as Exhibits B
and C, respectively.
Dr. Klassen, for his part, stated in his declaration: “I have been retained … to
review this lawsuit and the facts and circumstances surrounding the claims asserted[,]
from the p[er]spective of an expert witness physician who has a specialty in the field of
orthopedic surgery.” He added: “I make this declaration in order to set forth my
understanding of the facts based upon the materials I have reviewed, my opinions
regarding the medical care and treatment rendered to the patient, Fred Jackson, and issues
of causation regarding the subject matter of this lawsuit as they specifically pertain to
[Dr. Perry[, deceased[,] in light of my education, training, background, qualifications and
7.
experience.” Dr. Klassen further declared that “[a]s an additional basis for [his] opinions
set forth in this [d]eclaration,” he reviewed Jackson’s medical records from AHTV and
“Adventist Health Physicians Network, Jose Bosque, M.D.,” as “attached to the
Declaration of Gary L. Logan as Exhibit ‘B’ and Exhibit ‘C.’ ” (Italics added.)
Dr. Klassen explained the chronology of events concerning Dr. Perry’s role in
Jackson’s treatment. He noted that when Jackson presented to AHTV on October 3,
2020, “[x]-rays of the left shoulder were taken and read by [Dr. Perry], with findings and
impressions of ‘no fracture or malalignment.’ ” When Jackson returned to AHTV
approximately three weeks later, on October 23, 2020, with continued pain in the left
shoulder, “[a]dditional left shoulder x-rays were taken and read by [Dr. Perry][.]” “On
this occasion, Dr. Perry’s impression was, ‘[p]osterior dislocation of the shoulder.’ ”
“Discharge instructions for the October 23, 2020 visit included that [Jackson] should,
‘follow up with… ortho ASAP within 1-2 days.’ ”
Dr. Klassen noted: “[Jackson’s] next visit was to Jose Bosque, M.D., an
orthopedist at Adventist Health Physicians Network … on October 30, 2020, which was
within four weeks of the original x-ray read on October 3, 202[0].” He added: “At the
October 30, 2020 visit with Dr. Bosque, five (5) radiologic images were obtained
showing a posterior dislocation of the left shoulder with a reverse Hill-Sachs deformity.
It was recommended [Jackson] go to the [emergency department] for shoulder
reduction.”
Dr. Klassen further declared that Jackson subsequently presented at Dr. Bosque’s
office on November 20, 2020, “approximately seven (7) weeks after the initial x-ray read
by Dr. Perry [on] October 3, 2020.” “On this November 20, 2020 visit, [Jackson] noted
he felt better and the shoulder deformity resolved. Dr. Bosque noted that as the shoulder
dislocation is now reduced, there is no need for urgent reduction and trial of conservative
management is what is warranted.” Dr. Klassen explained: “Dr. Bosque discussed with
[Jackson] that surgery was to reduce his dislocated shoulder, but since he [was] now
8.
reduced, he [did] not need to have surgery. Dr. Bosque recommended a trial of
conservative management[;] if [Jackson] continued to have instability, he may then [later]
need surgical intervention.”
Dr. Klassen clarified that Jackson “eventually had surgery with Dr. Bosque on
March 9, 2021[,] for left shoulder posterior instability.”
Dr. Klassen addressed the specific characteristics of the type of injury that Jackson
had suffered. He noted: “With a posterior dislocation of the shoulder joint, as was the
case with [Jackson], with or without a fracture of the humeral head, there is a limited time
in which to repair such an injury and obtain a good result. As a rule of thumb, most
orthopedic surgeons think that a maximum of four (4) to six (6) weeks to repair is
critical.” He added: “[W]ith this type of injury, rotator cuff and/or labral damage may
occur and if one does not address the injury in the 4-6 week time frame … it is highly
difficult to get good function restored in the shoulder.”
Dr. Klassen explained: “Even if one were to assume there was a mis-read of the
October 3, 2020 x-rays by Dr. Perry, there was a re-read of the x-rays taken on the second
visit to [AHTV] on October 23, 2020, less than three weeks later, again by Dr. Perry.
This is not a substantial delay, since the dislocation was read by Dr. Perry within the 4-6
week window within which to repair, if necessary.” Further, “[a]ny mis-read of x-rays on
October 3, 2020 by Dr. Perry did not cause any permanent impairment … because …
surgery was not recommended by Dr. Bosque within the 4-6 week window[.]” Rather,
by the time of Jackson’s return visit to Dr. Bosque on November 20, 2020, “seven weeks
post-October 3, 2020, [his] left shoulder was reduced, there was no need for surgery, and
a conservative management program was begun.”
Dr. Klassen concluded that because Jackson was referred to Dr. Bosque within the
applicable four-to-six-week window for optimal surgical repair of his shoulder injury,
any misread of the initial x-rays on October 3, 2020, by Dr. Perry did not cause any
future problems with Jackson’s shoulder. Specifically, Dr. Klassen concluded: “[I]t is
9.
my professional opinion that to a reasonable degree of medical probability, there is
nothing that Dr. Perry either negligently did or did not do that played a substantial factor
in causing [Jackson’s] current conditions, complaints, or need for surgery.”
C. Alleged Concealment of Medical Records
Jackson contends that attorney Logan manipulated evidence provided to
Dr. Klassen in that he concealed certain medical records from Dr. Klassen. However,
Jackson does not provide evidence to support these claims, nor does he show that the
alleged concealment was material to Dr. Klassen’s opinions.
Jackson suggests that attorney Logan concealed documents that appear in the
clerk’s transcript at pages 208, 209, and 223, as part of the records attached to attorney
Logan’s declaration. Jackson’s contention that these documents were “concealed” is
incorrect because all the records attached to attorney Logan’s declaration were provided
to Dr. Klassen, as noted in Dr. Klassen’s own declaration.
Jackson further suggests that attorney Logan concealed from Dr. Klassen a post-
surgery radiology note signed by Dr. Perry on March 26, 2021, that documents
“acromioclavicular and coracoclavicular separations.” 6 Jackson’s contention that
attorney Logan deliberately concealed this post-surgery radiology note is not persuasive.
First, the records from Dr. Bosque’s office provided to Dr. Klassen contain a note signed
by Dr. Perry that is substantively identical to the note Jackson contends was improperly
concealed; both notes are dated March 26, 2021, and contain the same information.
Second, Jackson has not established the relevance or significance of the allegedly
concealed note, with respect to his claim of medical negligence on Dr. Perry’s part.
6 This document is attached to Jackson’s summary judgment opposition. Jackson
states it is part of his records from Adventist Health Bakersfield Hospital, where his
March 9, 2021, surgery with Dr. Bosque occurred. It appears Jackson obtained this
document, among other records, from the California Department of Corrections and
Rehabilitation.
10.
Jackson appears to argue that the allegedly concealed radiology note establishes
that Dr. Perry did not correctly diagnose his “acromioclavicular and coracoclavicular
separations” until March 26, 2021, after he had undergone surgery by Dr. Bosque.
Jackson asserts that this allegedly delayed diagnosis reveals that Dr. Perry’s earlier x-ray
reading—rendered months earlier on October 23, 2020, when Jackson presented for the
second time to AHTV’s emergency department—was flawed because it did not mention
any “acromioclavicular and coracoclavicular separations.”
To the extent Jackson is attempting to argue that Dr. Perry misread his October 23,
2020, x-rays, or for that matter, his October 3, 2020 x-rays, in this regard, that argument
does not help him. The record shows that on October 23, 2020, Dr. Perry documented his
impression that Jackson had a posterior dislocation of the left shoulder and that Jackson
thereafter timely came under the care of Dr. Bosque, an orthopedist. When Jackson first
presented to Dr. Bosque’s office on October 30, 2020, new images were taken of his left
shoulder; the new images were read by medical personnel associated with Dr. Bosque’s
office; and the next steps in his treatment were directed by Dr. Bosque on that basis.
Specifically, the record for Jackson’s October 30, 2020, visit to Dr. Bosque’s office
states: “5 images were obtained of the left shoulder. There is posterior dislocation of the
humeral head in relationship to the glenoid. There is a reverse Hill-Sachs deformity. The
acromioclavicular joint is anatomically aligned.” 7 Jackson was timely referred to Dr.
Bosque for specialist care based on Dr. Perry’s reading of his October 23, 2020, x-rays.
7 The post-surgery March 26, 2021, radiology note that Jackson alleges was
concealed lists radiology studies or reports from October 30, 2020, as the underlying
“comparison.” (Capitalization omitted.)
11.
Thereafter, Jackson’s treatment was based on imaging, diagnoses, and assessments
rendered by Dr. Bosque’s office. 8 9
We conclude Jackson has not shown that the trial court erred or abused its
discretion by considering Dr. Klassen’s declaration in granting summary judgment to the
estate of Dr. Perry. (See Sargon Enterprises, Inc. v. University of Southern California
(2012) 55 Cal.4th 747, 773 [we review the trial court’s “ruling excluding or admitting
expert testimony for abuse of discretion”].)
D. Alleged Alteration of Medical Records
Jackson further argues that defense counsel fraudulently or improperly altered
records. Jackson’s surgery by Dr. Bosque apparently took place at Adventist Health
Bakersfield Hospital, not at AHTV. Jackson attached medical records related to his
surgery to his summary judgment opposition, including a three-page “Office/Clinic
8 On October 30, 2020, Dr. James Cusator and Dr. Bosque reviewed images of
Jackson’s shoulder taken at Dr. Bosque’s office; Jackson was diagnosed with
“[d]islocation of shoulder, posterior, left, closed.” Dr. Bosque recommended Jackson
return to AHTV’s emergency department for “shoulder reduction.” Subsequently, on
November 20, 2020, Dr. Bosque determined Jackson’s shoulder had been reduced,
obviating the need for surgery, and that a trial period of “conservative management [was]
warranted.” Dr. Bosque’s record for Jackson’s November 20, 2020, visit further
indicates that post-reduction MRI imaging of Jackson’s left shoulder was conducted.
Dr. Bosque reviewed the imaging and concluded that “since [Jackson] is now reduced[,]
he does not need to have surgery.”
9 Furthermore, Dr. Perry’s estate notes: “[Jackson] never alleged [in his
pleadings] that Dr. Perry negligently failed to diagnose acromioclavicular and
coracoclavicular separation; [Jackson] alleged only that there was a misdiagnosis of his
shoulder dislocation. [Citations.] [Jackson cannot] oppose summary judgment by raising
a new theory of liability.” (Italics added.) We agree. (See Hutton v. Fidelity National
Title Co. (2013) 213 Cal.App.4th 486, 499 [“[f]or purposes of a summary judgment
motion, the pleadings set the boundaries of the issues to be resolved”; “[a] defendant
[need not] refute liability on some theoretical possibilities not included in the pleadings”];
Huntsman-West Foundation v. Smith (2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 1117, 1132 [“summary
judgment is defined by the material allegations in the pleadings”].)
12.
Notes” document dated March 26, 2021.10 The first two pages of this document describe
a “[p]ost-op” appointment with Dr. Bosque and are signed by Dr. Bosque; the last page is
the aforementioned post-surgery radiology note signed by Dr. Perry on March 26,
2021. 11 Jackson contends defense counsel “altered Adventist Health Bakersfield records
when he changed the … page numbers in the March 26, 2021 medical records from 1 of 3
to 1 of 2[.]”
Jackson’s contention is premised on a comparison of the three-page “Office/Clinic
Notes” document dated March 26, 2021, that is attached to his summary judgment
opposition with a two-page document also dated March 26, 2021, that defense counsel
provided to Dr. Klassen as part of Exhibit C (that is, Dr. Bosque’s records from Adventist
Health Physicians Network). Jackson asserts the two documents are identical and that
defense counsel altered the document he provided to Dr. Klassen by falsely labeling it as
a two-page document and removing its third and final page, that is, the post-surgery
radiology note signed by Dr. Perry on March 26, 2021.
Dr. Perry’s estate responds: “[Jackson] appears to be conflating two separate
documents: (1) the three-page Office/Clinic Notes [document,] which describe a
March 26, 2021 appointment with Dr. Bosque [citation]; and (2) a two-page ‘Final
Report’ by Dr. Bosque also dated March 26, 2021 [citation].” Dr. Perry’s estate adds:
“These documents are largely identical, but have some differences, including the header
and footer. The most salient difference is that the Office/Clinic Notes include a
[r]adiology [n]ote by Dr. Perry, which is not attached to the Final Report.” 12 Dr. Perry’s
10 It appears Jackson obtained this document, among other records, from the
California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation.
11 In his briefs, Jackson states that the three-page report dated March 26, 2021,
attached to his summary judgment opposition, is part of his Adventist Health Bakersfield
Hospital records.
12 However, as noted above, a document that is substantively identical to this
radiology note, was included in the records provided by defense counsel to Dr. Klassen.
13.
estate concludes: “Put simply, there is no evidence that defense counsel manipulated
either of these documents. [Jackson’s] argument appears to boil down to a
misunderstanding that these were one document at some point. But they were not; they
are two separate documents.”
We agree with Dr. Perry’s estate that the two documents contain similar
information but are not identical. Jackson’s argument that defense counsel altered the
document he provided to Dr. Klassen therefore fails. In turn, we find no abuse of
discretion in the trial court’s consideration of Dr. Klassen’s declaration in granting
summary judgment to the estate of Dr. Perry.
E. Jackson’s Ancillary Contentions
Jackson next argues that he was “denied due process and equal protection of the
law” when the trial court rejected his argument that defense counsel had “intentionally
concealed” evidence from Dr. Klassen. He also argues that defense counsel violated
Penal Code sections 132, 134, and 135, by altering AHTV medical records. None of
these arguments are adequately developed and are therefore forfeited. (See In re S.C.
(2006) 138 Cal.App.4th 396, 408 [“[I]t is appellant’s burden to affirmatively show error.
[Citation.] To demonstrate error, appellant must present meaningful legal analysis
supported by citations to authority and citations to facts in the record that support the
claim of error”]; Singh v. Lipworth (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th 813, 817 [“We consider all
points asserted in this appeal to be forfeited as unsupported by ‘adequate factual or legal
analysis’ ”].)
Jackson’s argument that defense counsel’s conduct violates Penal Code
section 132—which makes it a felony to offer as true, fraudulently altered documents, in
a legal proceeding—also fails on the merits because this statute does not create a private
right of action. (See Willis v. City of Los Angeles (9th Cir. 2002) 57 Fed.Appx. 283, 289
[affirming district court’s grant of summary judgment on basis that there is no private
right of action for violation of Penal Code section 132].) Jackson’s references to Penal
14.
Code sections 134 and 135, both of which are also criminal statutes, are unavailing for
the same reason.
II. Court Did Not Err in Denying Jackson’s Motion for Appointment of Expert
On January 6, 2025, Jackson had filed a motion or request for a “[c]ourt-
[a]ppointed [e]xpert if [n]eeded” in the trial court, given the then-pending summary
judgment motion filed by Dr. Perry’s estate. Jackson did not clarify the type of expert
witness he sought to have appointed or specifically identify the issues he would have any
court-appointed expert witness address.
Jackson noted in his request that Dr. Perry’s estate had provided a declaration
from Dr. Klassen in support of its summary judgment motion. Jackson asserted that
defense counsel had “manipulatively concealed” relevant records from Dr. Klassen,
rendering his opinions unsound. Jackson alleged that defense counsel had concealed
from Dr. Klassen, the March 26, 2021, post-surgery, radiology note signed by Dr. Perry,
in which Dr. Perry had documented “acromioclavicular and coracoclavicular
separations.” Jackson asserted that Dr. Perry’s post-surgery diagnosis indicated that his
earlier x-ray reading—rendered months earlier on October 23, 2020, when Jackson
presented for the second time to AHTV’s emergency department—was flawed because it
did not document the same “acromioclavicular and coracoclavicular separations.” In his
January 6, 2025, motion, Jackson appeared to seek an expert to confirm his hypothesis
regarding defense counsel’s allegedly misleading actions; he did not state that he sought
an expert to affirmatively establish causation.
The record indicates that Jackson’s January 6, 2025, motion was not the first
motion for a court-appointed expert that he had filed in the trial court. It appears that he
previously filed, on May 31, 2023, a “motion for appointment of an expert witness for
trial in limine.” (Capitalization omitted.) The court apparently denied the earlier motion
on grounds that appointment of an expert was not feasible under Evidence Code sections
730 and 731.
15.
As for Jackson’s January 6, 2025, motion for a court-appointed expert witness at
issue here, the trial court heard it on February 14, 2025, at the same time as it heard the
estate’s summary judgment motion. The court denied Jackson’s motion. The court noted
that denial of the motion in this instance did not vitiate Jackson’s right to meaningful
access to the courts.
Jackson challenges the trial court’s denial of his request for a court-appointed
expert witness. He argues the trial court should have appointed an expert for him once it
“became aware” that defense counsel had “altered and arranged the concealment of
relevant medical records” from Dr. Klassen, “in order to obtain [a] favorable expert
opinion” on the issue of causation. He argues the court’s ruling was an abuse of
discretion. We disagree.
A. Applicable Law and Analysis
It is well settled that “ ‘a prisoner may not be deprived, by his or her inmate status,
of meaningful access to the civil courts if the prisoner is both indigent and a party to a
bona fide civil action threatening his or her personal or property interests.’ ” (Hulbert v.
Cross (2021) 65 Cal.App.5th 405, 413 (Hulbert).) However, “ ‘while “[m]eaningful
access to the courts is the ‘keystone’ of an indigent prisoner’s right to … prosecute bona
fide civil actions,” ’ ” such right does not necessarily mandate a particular remedy to
secure access. (Id. at p. 413.) As pertinent here, “ ‘the discretionary appointment of an
expert pursuant to Evidence Code section 730 is among the measures available to trial
courts to ensure indigent prisoner litigants are afforded meaningful access to the
courts.’ ” (Id. at p. 414, italics added.) “Ultimately, ‘a trial court must examine the
totality of the circumstances when making the discretionary determination of whether an
inmate’s access is being impeded.’ ” (Ibid.)
Evidence Code section 730 provides in relevant part:
“When it appears to the court, at any time before or during the trial of an
action, that expert evidence is or may be required by the court or by any
16.
party to the action, the court on its own motion or on motion of any party
may appoint one or more experts to investigate, to render a report as may
be ordered by the court, and to testify as an expert at the trial of the action
relative to the fact or matter as to which the expert evidence is or may be
required. The court may fix the compensation for these services, if any,
rendered by any person appointed under this section, in addition to any
service as a witness, at the amount as seems reasonable to the court.”
This section gives the trial court discretion to appoint an expert on a party’s
motion; it does not confer on a party an absolute right to have an expert appointed.
(Laguna Salada Union Elementary School Dist. v. Pacific Development Co. (1953)
119 Cal.App.2d 470, 474 [interpreting former § 1871, predecessor to Evid. Code, § 730].)
We review the trial court’s decision for abuse of discretion. (In re Marriage of E.U. &
J.E. (2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 1377, 1389.)
The question of payment of potential court-appointed experts is addressed in
Evidence Code section 731. Regarding experts potentially appointed in civil actions, it
provides:
“(b) In any county in which the superior court so provides, the
compensation fixed under Section 730 for medical experts appointed for the
court’s needs in civil actions shall be a charge against the court. In any
county in which the board of supervisors so provides, the compensation
fixed under Section 730 for medical experts appointed in civil actions, for
purposes other than the court’s needs, shall be a charge against and paid out
of the treasury of that county on order of the court.
“(c) Except as otherwise provided in this section, in all civil actions, the
compensation fixed under Section 730 shall, in the first instance, be
apportioned and charged to the several parties in a proportion as the court
may determine and may thereafter be taxed and allowed in like manner as
other costs.” (Evid. Code, § 731, subds. (b), (c).)
Here, there was no basis for the court to appoint an expert for its own needs.
Rather, Jackson sought appointment of an expert for his purposes, specifically to bolster
his claim that defense counsel had improperly concealed or altered his medical records in
a deliberate ploy to mislead Dr. Klassen. However, Jackson did not adduce any evidence
showing that defense counsel had improperly manipulated the medical records provided
17.
to Dr. Klassen. Nor did Jackson directly articulate other, better-supported reasons for
seeking appointment of an expert; for example, he did not expressly contend that he
sought an expert witness to provide an opinion on causation. As noted above, the
existing record indicates that Jackson timely presented to Dr. Bosque’s office on October
30, 2020; at that time, new images were taken of his left shoulder; the images were read
by medical personnel associated with Dr. Bosque’s office; and his treatment was directed
by Dr. Bosque on that basis.
Under Evidence Code section 731, subdivision (b), compensation for any court-
appointed expert would be chargeable to the county treasury only if the board of
supervisors of the county had provided for such compensation and if the trial court
ordered it. Jackson has presented no evidence or authority establishing that the board of
supervisors of Kern County had provided for payment for court-appointed medical
experts in civil cases to be made from the county treasury.
Under Evidence Code section 731, subdivision (c), the compensation of any
appointed expert initially would be charged to one or more parties as determined by the
court, subject to subsequent recovery as a cost by the prevailing party. Evidence Code
section 731, subdivision (c), does not authorize the court to appoint an expert for a party
at public expense.
Here, the record reflects that the trial court was aware it had the discretion to
consider appointing an expert for Jackson pursuant to Evidence Code sections 730 and
731, in furtherance of his right to meaningful access to the courts. The court exercised its
informed discretion, and considering all the circumstances, declined to appoint an expert
witness for Jackson at public expense. We conclude the court’s ruling was not an abuse
of discretion.
III. Jackson Did Not Appear at Summary Judgment Motion Hearing
The estate’s motion for summary judgment was heard on February 14, 2025;
Jackson’s motion for a court-appointed expert was heard on the same date. Jackson did
18.
not appear for the hearing. Jackson had routinely been allowed to appear for hearings by
telephone from prison and did so for several hearings. The trial court’s register of actions
shows that Jackson filed a notice to appear by telephone, on January 10, 2025, and that
the court thereafter sent a Court Call confirmation cover sheet to the prison. None of
these documents are in the record; nor does the record contain a reporter’s transcript or
settled statement of the February 14, 2025, hearing. In short, there is no evidence that the
court in any way prevented Jackson from appearing at the February 14, 2025, hearing.
Jackson argues the court violated his “right to a fair hearing … under the
California Constitution[,] which warrant[s] the ruling on summary judgment being
vacated and [the matter] remanded” for further proceedings.
“An appellant bears the burden to show not only that the trial court erred, but also
that the error was prejudicial in that it resulted in a miscarriage of justice. [Citations.]
An error is prejudicial and results in a miscarriage of justice only if the reviewing court
concludes, based on its review of the entire record, that it is reasonably probable that the
trial court would have reached a result more favorable to the appellant absent the error.”
(Jones v. Farmers Ins. Exchange (2013) 221 Cal.App.4th 986, 999 (Jones).)
Here, Jackson has not established error by the trial court in ruling on the summary
judgment motion in his absence. Even if there were some error by the court in this
context, Jackson has not shown the error was prejudicial. He has not identified any facts
or legal authorities that he would have presented had he appeared at the February 14,
2025, hearing, that would have affected the court’s decision. Furthermore, the court did
not grant summary judgment or dismiss the case, based on Jackson’s failure to appear.
We conclude Jackson has not demonstrated any prejudicial error with regard to his
nonappearance at the hearing on the estate’s motion for summary judgment. 13
13 On February 10, 2026, Jackson filed a motion for judicial notice in conjunction
with his opening brief. He asked us to take judicial notice of four sets of documents that
he categorized in four exhibits, Exhibits A, B, C, and D. Exhibit A contains two minute
19.
IV. Jackson’s Unclean Hands Argument is Inapposite
Finally, Jackson argues that Dr. Perry’s estate and attorney Logan “are barred
from relief having violated the ‘unclean hands doctrine,’ after altering and concealment
of medical records relevant to the issue of causation from their retained expert
witness[, Dr. Klassen].” (Capitalization omitted.) Jackson adds: “It should be noted that
in defendant’s counsel[’]s fraudulent concealment he violated Penal Code sections 132 in
altering the records but also [Penal Code sections] 134 and 135 which are felonies. In
addition[,] he violated the [un]clean hands doctrine … and is barred from relief.”
Dr. Perry’s estate responds: “[T]here is no evidence of any manipulation of
documents nor improper concealment. Moreover, unclean hands is an affirmative
defense that can be raised by a defendant in the trial court; it may not be raised by a
plaintiff for the first time on appeal to challenge a judgment. (Scannell v. Murphy (1947)
82 Cal.App.2d 844, 849 [‘the “unclean hands” doctrine must be raised in the trial court to
be available as a defense, and cannot, as here, be raised for the first time on appeal’].)”
We agree with Dr. Perry’s estate. Jackson has not shown he can properly raise the
unclean hands defense under the applicable circumstances.
orders entered by the trial court, as well as a few entries on the court’s register of actions
for this matter. We grant Jackson’s request for judicial notice as to Exhibit A. (Evid.
Code, §§ 452, subd. (d), 459.) We deny his request for judicial notice as to Exhibits B,
C, and D because he has not demonstrated the relevance of this material or that these
documents were filed before the trial court. (See Doe v. City of Los Angeles (2007)
42 Cal.4th 531, 544, fn. 4.)
With regard to Exhibit A, it contains: (1) a minute order from October 25, 2024,
indicating that an attorney made a limited appearance on Jackson’s behalf at a hearing
held that day; (2) a minute order from January 7, 2025, indicating Jackson did not appear
for a hearing that day, evidently because the prison did not have notice he had a hearing
on that date; and (3) register of actions entries for January 7, 2025, and February 14,
2025. The documents in Exhibit A do not change our conclusion because they do not
show the trial court was responsible for Jackson’s nonappearance at the February 14,
2025, hearing.
20.
V. Conclusion
Jackson has raised no viable challenge to the validity of the trial court’s order
granting the estate’s motion for summary judgment. 14 We therefore see no reason to
disturb the court’s decision and affirm the judgment. 15 (Claudio v. Regents of University
of California (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 224, 230 [“ ‘[I]t is the appellant’s responsibility to
affirmatively demonstrate error and, therefore, to point out the triable issues the appellant
claims are present by citation to the record and any supporting authority.’ ”].)
DISPOSITION
The judgment is affirmed. Dr. Perry’s Estate is entitled to its costs on appeal.
SNAUFFER, J.
WE CONCUR:
DETJEN, Acting P. J.
MEEHAN, J.
14 To the extent Jackson raises various new arguments for the first time in his
reply brief, we decline to consider them. (Champir, LLC v. Fairbanks Ranch Assn.
(2021) 66 Cal.App.5th 583, 591, fn. 3 [“ ‘Normally, a contention may not be raised for
the first time in a reply brief.’ ”].)
15 On June 16, 2026, Jackson filed another request for judicial notice, attaching
four exhibits. Jackson sought judicial notice of these documents to challenge a request
for extension of time filed by Dr. Perry’s estate as to the deadline for filing its
respondent’s brief. Jackson’s request for judicial notice is denied as moot as this matter
has been fully briefed.
21.