Filed 10/26/26 He v. Metropolitan Transit System CA4/1
NOT TO BE PUBLISHED IN OFFICIAL REPORTS
California Rules of Court, rule 8.1115(a), prohibits courts and parties from citing or relying on opinions
not certified for publication or ordered published, except as specified by rule 8.1115(b). This opinion
has not been certified for publication or ordered published for purposes of rule 8.1115.
COURT OF APPEAL, FOURTH APPELLATE DISTRICT
DIVISION ONE
STATE OF CALIFORNIA
SHUXIA HE, Individually and as D085566
Successor in Interest, etc. et al.,
Plaintiffs and Appellants,
(Super. Ct. No. 37-2021-
v.
00002319-CU-PO-CTL)
METROPOLITAN TRANSIT SYSTEM
et al.,
Defendants and Respondents.
APPEAL from a judgment of the Superior Court of San Diego County,
Carolyn M. Caietti, Judge. Affirmed.
Strongin, LLP, Eric B. Strongin and Daniel J. Libbey for Plaintiffs and
Appellants.
Hanson Bridgett LLP, Alexandra V. Atencio, Patrick Burns and Breana
L. Burgos for Defendant and Respondent Metropolitan Transit System.
Sims Law Firm, Michael E. Murphy, Jerome D. Rybarczyk and Selim
Mounedji for Defendant and Respondent North County Transit District.
Bremer Whyte Brown & O’Meara and JohnPaul Salem for Defendant
and Respondent San Diego Association of Governments.
Wentian Zheng was struck and killed by a moving Amtrak train just
after 4:00 p.m. on February 18, 2020. Zheng had just exited a trolley
operated by the Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) and had attempted to
cross the parallel tracks utilized by Amtrak at the Washington Street
railroad station (the Washington Street Station).
Zheng’s wife, Shuxia He, and daughters, Lillian Zheng, Lihong Zheng,
and Lihua Zheng (collectively, Appellants or the Zhengs), sued MTS, North
County Transit District (NCTD), and the San Diego Association of
Governments (SANDAG) (collectively, Respondents).1 They asserted claims
for dangerous condition of public property (Gov. Code § 835)2 and negligence
(§ 815.2) against Respondents, based primarily on the layout of the
Washington Street Station and the presence of a masonry wall separating the
two sets of parallel tracks.
The trial court granted motions for summary judgment filed by each of
the Respondents based on governmental immunity. The Zhengs appeal and
assert that the grant of summary judgment was error and that triable issues
of material fact remain. On our own independent review, we affirm the
summary judgments.
1 The Zhengs also asserted causes of action for negligence and wrongful
death against other defendants who were subsequently dismissed. Those
claims are not at issue in this appeal.
2 Further unspecified statutory references are to the Government Code.
2
I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
A. The Complaint3
In their complaint (the Complaint), the Zhengs allege: “On February
18, 2020, Decedent was struck and killed by a Pacific Surfliner Amtrak train
near the Washington Street trolley station (the ‘Incident’).[4] Plaintiff Shuxia
He, Decedent’s wife of 55 years, was only a few feet from her husband when
he was tragically killed by the train and witnessed the events.”
“[A]t approximately 4:10 p.m., Decedent and his wife . . . disembarked
a[n] MTS trolley at the Washington Street Station, located at 2136 West
Washington Street, San Diego, California 92110 (the ‘Subject Location’).”[5]
“After exiting the trolley, Decedent and his wife walked south on the
pedestrian sidewalk of the Washington Street Station, next to a wall which
completely obstructed their view of the Amtrak tracks on their right. The
couple were making their way to the bus stop located west of the Washington
Street Station, at the intersection of Washington Street and Pacific Coast
Highway, to board a bus and return to their home.” “When Decedent reached
the end of the wall, he turned right (west) toward the bus stop, and was
immediately hit by southbound Amtrak train #A578.”
According to the Complaint, “At the time of the Incident, the Subject
Location had numerous dangerous conditions,” including:
3 The Complaint notes that Appellants timely served written government
claims, which were rejected, before proceeding to the Complaint. Appellants’
compliance with this process is not at issue on appeal.
4 We will adopt this definition of “the Incident” throughout our opinion.
5 We will adopt this definition of “Subject Location” throughout our
opinion.
3
“A wall which obstructed pedestrians’ ability to realize,
understand and comprehend the danger of southbound
Amtrak trains immediately to their right (west) of the wall;
“A wall which was constructed only a few feet from the
southbound Amtrak tracks such that it created an
extremely dangerous condition for pedestrians proceeding
right (west) at the end of the wall;
“No signage or other warnings to alert pedestrians that
active southbound Amtrak train tracks were only a few feet
to the right (west) of the wall;
“Insufficient signage or warnings to alert pedestrians that
active Amtrak train tracks were only a few feet to the right
(west) of the wall;
“No signage or other warnings that pedestrians should look
both ways before turning right (west) at the end of the wall
running along the pedestrian sidewalk;
“Insufficient signage or other warnings that pedestrians
should look both ways before turning right (west) at the
end of the wall running along the pedestrian sidewalk;
“No pavement markings on the pedestrian sidewalk
warning pedestrians to watch for moving trains at the end
of the wall before proceeding right (west) at the end of the
wall;
“Insufficient pavement markings on the pedestrian
sidewalk warning pedestrians to watch for moving trains at
the end of the wall before proceeding right (west) at the end
of the wall;
“No safety measures to prevent or impede pedestrians from
unknowingly stepping into the path of a southbound
Amtrak train, including but not limited to a physical
barrier and/or gate; and
“Signage, lights, and bells which confused and misled
pedestrians regarding the areas of danger due to moving
trains and vehicles, thereby significantly increasing the
risk of serious injury or death.”
4
The Zhengs alleged that there had been other deaths at the Subject
Location and that Respondents “did nothing to improve the dangerous
conditions.” In addition, they alleged that there was a “Look Both Ways” sign
and a “Watch For Moving Trains” pavement marking at the Subject Location
that were removed sometime after April 2014 and before the Incident.
Finally, they alleged that Respondents were common carriers with
heightened duties; that they violated “various government safety
regulations”; and that they had actual or constructive notice of the dangerous
conditions at a sufficient time period prior to the Incident to have taken
measures to protect against the dangerous condition.
Based on these allegations, the Zhengs asserted causes of action for
dangerous condition of public property (§ 835) and negligence (§ 815.2). The
allegations in the Complaint supporting each cause of action are nearly
identical and each includes the same list of alleged dangerous conditions
created by the design, construction, maintenance, and repair of the
Washington Street Station.
B. The Motions for Summary Judgment
MTS, NCTD, and SANDAG each filed a motion for summary judgment.
In its motion, MTS summarized the Zhengs’ claims as:
“[T]he Washington Street Station/Crossing constitutes a
dangerous condition of public property for the following
reasons: (1) a concrete wall separating the light-rail/heavy-
rail tracks in the Washington Street Station presents a
visual obstruction to the heavy-rail tracks to persons in the
Station; (2) absent and/or inadequate signage to alert
pedestrians of active heavy-rail tracks immediately west of
the Station; (3) absence of signage/warnings that
pedestrians should ‘look both ways’ before turning west at
the end of the wall on the public sidewalk; (4) absence of
pavement markings on the public sidewalk warning
pedestrians to ‘watch for moving trains’; and (5) absence of
safety devices, including physical barriers and/or gates to
5
prevent or impede pedestrians from stepping into the path
of a southbound heavy-rail train.”
MTS, NCTD, and SANDAG each asserted that they could not be liable
for either cause of action because they were entitled to design immunity
under section 830.6. In addition, MTS argued that section 835 also precluded
liability (i.e. provided a different form of immunity) because there was no
evidence that it had actual or constructive notice of any alleged dangerous
condition at the Washington Street Station before the Incident.
In support of the design immunity contention, MTS asserted that it is
subject to the regulations of the [CPUC], “the regulatory agency designated
by the Legislature to adopt rules and regulations regarding the procedures
for all rail transit systems in California.” MTS explained that it had
submitted an application to the CPUC for the “Old Town LRT [light rail]
Extension Project”—which included the addition of the light rail tracks at the
Washington Street Station—and that the application included “plan view
drawings which had been prepared considered and approved by a certified
design engineer and [Metropolitan Transit Development Board (MTDB)]
Project Engineer (David Ragland).” The CPUC issued a written decision
authorizing the construction of the station per the design plans and noted
therein that the plans were reviewed by the CPUC’s safety division traffic
engineering staff. After completion of the project, “the plans were stamped
with a certified engineer’s as-built stamp,” certifying that the Washington
Street Station was “built in compliance with [the] pre-approved plans.” Thus,
MTS asserted, the design was both reasonable and approved by qualified
engineers.
NCTD asserted that it had no authority to install safety devices
because the CPUC had exclusive authority, and NCTD did not maintain
control of the sidewalk or surrounding area. In response to a contention from
6
the Zhengs that it should have changed the manner in which trains use the
parallel heavy rail tracks (i.e., the direction of travel on the easternmost
track), NCTD asserted that its “decision to have southbound trains use the
easternmost track and northbound trains use the westernmost track where
there are parallel tracks, implemented in approximately 2018, [was]
reasonable and based on station and platform placement along the coastal
corridor.”
SANDAG explained that it had completed certain upgrades to
underground conduit at the Washington Street Station 18 months and 10
months before the Incident. Those upgrades required demolishing and re-
pouring a slab of sidewalk. SANDAG asserted that all its repairs were done
according to the approved as-built design plans. Like MTS, SANDAG relied
on the as-built drawings signed by registered engineer, Mark Randall, as well
as hardscape plans that were designed, drafted, reviewed, checked, and
approved by “the competent engineers at Estrada Land Planning.” They
noted that those plans did not call for any pavement or sidewalk markings at
the Subject Location.
C. Evidence Submitted in Support of the Motions for Summary
Judgment
1. MTS
MTS supported its motion with declarations from civil engineer,
Heather Furey, and system safety manager, Fabeann Soberg; copies of its
application to CPUC and CPUC’s written decision approving the Old Town
LRT Extension—including the addition of the Washington Street Station;
various design documents detailing the approved design; and excerpts from
the depositions of Appellant Shuxia He and Yuliang Xiao, another individual
that was present on the day of the Incident. MTS also provided videos of the
Incident and surrounding area taken from various cameras located at the
7
Washington Street trolley station, on the trolley, and on a bus that was
waiting across the street, along with declarations authenticating each.
a. Declaration of Heather Furey
Furey’s declaration provided background on MTS and the Old Town
LRT Extension project that resulted in the addition of the Washington Street
Station. Fury explained that the MTDB was MTS’s predecessor and existed
under the Public Utilities Code. Some of MTDB’s functions merged into
SANDAG, the regional metropolitan planning organization, in or around
2002, and the remaining MTDB entity changed its name to MTS in 2005.
Before that occurred, in 1991, MTDB acquired the Old Town Corridor
right-of-way, including the land underlying the Washington Street Station,
from the Atchison, Topeka, and Sante Fe Railroad Company (AT&SF). “On
March 25, 1993, MTDB filed Application No. 93-03-062 with the CPUC for
authority to construct the light rail system, known as the Old Town LRT
Extension Project . . . along parts of the recently purchased AT&SF right-of-
way . . . . The project included the construction of two (2) light rail tracks to
parallel existing freight/intercity/commuter rail tracks utilized by AT&SF
freight, Amtrak and future commuter rail agencies,” as well as several
crossings, including the one at the Subject Location.
Relevant to the issues raised in this case, Furey explained that “[p]er
design specifications, the LRT right-of-way and track is adjacent to and
parallel with freight/Amtrak/intercity heavy rail right-of-way and track, with
both crossing the subject streets at-grade. After review, consideration and
engineering analysis, MTDB determined it is not feasible to grade separate
the crossings because of the proximity to adjacent crossings, lack of sufficient
right-of-way, and the cost-benefit ratio associated with available funding [for]
at-grade crossings. Additionally, parallel LRT and heavy rail tracks are the
8
most financially/environmentally acceptable choices and is consistent with
the open-access concept of the light rail transit.”6
On June 22, 1994, CPUC issued a written decision indicating that it
had reviewed and approved MTDB’s proposal for the Old Town LRT
Extension Project. All safety and warning devices and signals to be installed
at the Washington Street Station and crossing “were subject to CPUC
General Order 75–C (superseded by 75-D; effective Sept. 22, 2006.) Pursuant
to Section 11 of General Order 75-D, ‘[t]he removal, reduction, addition, or
change in type of warning devices at each public at-grade crossing [ ] shall not
be permitted unless authorized by the Commission.’ ”
MTDB completed the work in June 1996, and received authorization
from CPUC to commence service that same month. In December 1996,
MTDB requested authorization from CPUC to relocate a crossing gate and
cantilever in the northeast corner at Washington Street for crossing safety.
CPUC approved the request and, in its written decision dated April 23, 1997
specified that “protections at Washington Street at-grade crossing shall be
two Standard No. 9-A automatic gate-type signals with cantilevers, and three
Standard No. 9 flashing light-type signals (GO 75-C).” Neither MTDB,
CPUC, nor any other entity has requested or issued any other application for
change to the safety or warning devices at the Washington Street crossing.
b. Declaration of Fabeann Soberg
Fabeann Soberg, a system safety manager for MTS, declared: “I have
reviewed the relevant MTS business records relating to accidents/incidents
occurring at the Washington Street Station/Crossing for the eighteen (18)
6 “An ‘at-grade’ crossing is one that physically crosses the road at street
level. A ‘grade-separated’ crossing physically separates the train from traffic
by utilizing an overpass or underpass.” (Santa Clara Valley Transportation
Authority v. Public Utilities Com. (2004) 124 Cal.App.4th 346, 351, fn. 3.)
9
year period in which MTS has been designated to investigate accidents at
this location. I am unaware of and have not identified any heavy-rail versus
pedestrian accidents occurring at the Washington Street Crossing prior to the
subject date of loss on February 18, 2020, where a passenger alighting from a
light rail train at the Washington Street Station was struck by a heavy rail
train operating on the adjacent tracks west of the Station.”
2. NCTD
NCTD supported its motion for summary judgment with discovery
responses from the Zhengs; excerpts from the depositions of Appellant Shuxia
He and Yuliang Xiao; and declarations from NCTD Signal Manager, Brian
Shultz, and NCTD Director of Engineering, Scott Shroyer.
a. Declaration of Brian Shultz
Shultz described the layout of the Washington Street Station. He
explained that “[t]here are four north/south tracks at the Washington Street
grade crossing. The Washington Street trolley station is located just north of
the grade crossing. There is a safety wall between the Washington Street
trolley station and the two NCTD heavy rail tracks on the west side of the
safety wall. The trolley station is on the east side of the safety wall, and has
two light rail tracks for Metropolitan Transit System (MTS) trolleys, all of
which stop at the station. The south end of the trolley station platform ends
at the Washington Street public grade crossing sidewalk, which runs
east/west over all four tracks. Amtrak, Coaster and BNSF operate through
trains on the two sets of tracks on the west side of the wall.”
Shultz explained further: “At the time of the February 18, 2020
accident, the Washington Street public grade crossing was equipped with the
following warning devices: California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC)
approved warning devices including multiple sets of automatic flashing red
lights, multiple electronic bells, multiple gates, multiple cantilever structures
10
with more flashing red lights, pavement markings, railroad cross bucks,
number of tracks signs, and tactile strips at the corners, that were designed
to detect trains and trolleys approaching the grade crossing and provide more
than 30 seconds of warning that a train may be approaching. True and
correct copies of three annotated photographs showing the warning devices at
the Washington Street grade crossing are attached to this declaration as
Exhibits A–C.” Exhibits A and C are reproduced below.7
Exhibit A:
7 Shultz does not state the date upon which these photos were taken. We
note that there appear to be words stamped on a yellow background on the
sidewalk. As discussed herein, the parties agree that those stamps were not
present on the day of the accident. However, they also do not dispute that
the annotated warning devices were present.
11
Exhibit C:
Shultz stated the warning devices seen in these images “were in accord
with accepted industry standards for the given existing local conditions, in
accordance with CPUC General Order 75-D, Section 3. The warning devices
complied in every respect with CPUC General Order 75-D.” “Pursuant to the
provisions of an Amended and Shared Use Agreement, dated June 21, 2016,
MTS is responsible for maintenance and repair of signal and gate warning
devices for the light rail tracks to the east of the safety wall, and NCTD is
responsible for maintenance and repair of signal and gate warning devices for
the heavy rail tracks to the west of the safety wall. MTS, as the owner and
operator of the trolley station, is responsible for those premises. NCTD does
not own, operate, control or maintain the trolley station.” NCTD also “does
not control or maintain the sidewalk” that runs between the crossing.
12
Shultz explained that “NCTD has reported accidents at the Washington
Street grade crossing to both the Federal Railroad Administration and the
CPUC since at least 1994.” He reviewed the records from 1994 to February
18, 2020, and found “no record indicating that a westbound pedestrian was
struck by a southbound train on one of the heavy rail tracks. Furthermore,
[Shultz] found no record indicating that any person walking from the trolley
platform was struck by a train on the heavy rail tracks.”
b. Declaration of Scott Shroyer
Shroyer explained, “Since 1995, NCTD’s COASTER commuter train
has operated north/south train service between the Oceanside Transit Center
and the Santa Fe Depot in downtown San Diego. [¶ . . . ¶] Approximately
75% of the COASTER route consists [of] double-tracked segments where
there are two parallel tracks. [¶ . . . ¶] There is no federal rule, regulation or
standard that requires trains such as the COASTER commuter train to use a
specific track in areas where there are two or more parallel tracks (unlike
motor vehicles, which are required to drive on the right side of the road). [¶]
Operating practices on the COASTER route place southbound trains on the
easternmost track (MT 1) and northbound trains on the westernmost track
(MT 2). This practice and procedure is followed by Amtrak passenger trains
using the coastal corridor. [¶] In approximately 2018, NCTD gave
discretionary approval of the plan to have southbound COASTER commuter
trains use the easternmost track where there are two parallel tracks . . . .
The rationale for this decision was related to station and platform placement.
At stations with two platforms, passengers on the route can always expect to
board or exit a train on the left side of the train’s direction of travel, which is
reasonable since it promotes safety and the orderly flow of passenger traffic
to a station or platform.”
13
3. SANDAG
SANDAG supported its motion for summary judgment with excerpts of
the depositions of Shuxia He and Yuliang Xiao; a copy of the memorandum of
understanding between SANDAG, NCTD, and MTS; the as-built plans for the
Washington Street trolley station; and declarations from the Project and
General Superintendent for Mid-Coast Transit Constructors, Joshua Grimm,
SANDAG’s Director of Engineering and Construction, Sharon Humphreys,
Resident Engineer Hank Gentile, and civil engineering expert Rock Miller.
a. Declaration of Sharon Humphreys
Humphreys explained that SANDAG does not control and does not
perform any regular maintenance or upkeep on any light rail or heavy rail
train tracks, or any streets, roadways, or sidewalks surrounding the
Washington Street, or any other, light rail station. “SANDAG lacks the
authority or rights to make any modifications or changes to the [Washington
Street] Station or the [Subject] Location.”
b. Declaration of Hank Gentile
Gentile “was the Resident Engineer for SANDAG for the ‘Trolley
Renewal Project’ which [made modifications] and improvements to various
San Diego trolley stations consisting of larger shelters with new furnishings,
digital next arrival signs, and upgrades to the track and train signaling
system in order to accommodate the new ‘low-floor trolley’ vehicles, including
at the Washington Street Station.” The Trolley Renewal Project took place
between 2010 and 2015. Gentile explained that “Plans for the modifications
at the Station were designed and drafted by the engineers at CH2M Hill.
Prior to construction, the plans were reviewed, checked, and approved by the
CH2M Hill engineers. As the Resident Engineer, [Gentile] also reviewed the
plans prior to construction.” “The plans did not call for any pavement
markings at the [Subject] Location.”
14
c. Declaration of Joshua Grimm
Grimm explained, “In July 2015, MCTC contracted with [SANDAG] to
construct the Mid-Coast Corridor Improvements Project that would extend
the trolly light rail tracks from downtown San Diego to University City, La
Jolla, providing an alternative to congested roadways, improve public transit,
and enhance travel options.” This included upgrading the conduits at several
stations along the light rail track. Under Grimms’ supervision, “MCTC crews
performed phase one demolition and conduit duct bank upgrades at and
adjacent to” the Washington Street Station in August and September of 2018.
“During the phase one work performed in late August and early-mid
September 2018, new trenches were dug in the street and new conduits were
installed, and some existing conduits were replaced.”
Grimm did not recall seeing a “Look Both Ways” sign on the signal pole
at the Washington Street Station. MCTC crews did not move or alter the
pole during their work.
“On April 14–16, 2019, the street trenches were filled, compacted, and
covered with asphalt, and in the location where the sidewalk slab was
demolished, a new sidewalk slab was poured.” Under Grimm’s direction,
“MCTC crews followed the existing as-built plans for the Station which did
not include a ‘Watch For Moving Trains’ pavement stamp at the [Subject]
Location.” MCTC did not make any further changes between April 16, 2019,
and February 18, 2020, the date of the Incident.
d. Declaration of Rock Miller
Miller inspected the Washington Street Station and opined that “there
are no warning signs or other required or recommended signs and other
devices that were not present at or near the sidewalk in between the light
rail tracks and the heavy rail tracks at the time of the incident.” Likewise,
Miller opined that there was no requirement for a “Watch for Moving Trains”
15
sidewalk stamp, and stated that he had seen “no evidence to indicate that
MCTC’s work at the Washington Street Station involved anything more than
underground conduit upgrades and restoring the Washington Street Station
to its approved as-built condition which did not include a ‘Watch For Moving
Trains’ pavement stamp on the sidewalk.”
D. The Zhengs’ Motion for Continuance and Amended Opposition
to the Motions for Summary Judgment
Following the motions for summary judgment, the Zhengs filed an ex
parte application for continuance. They asserted that changes had been
made to the Washington Street Station after the accident, contradicting
claims by Respondents that the masonry wall had not been modified since it
was originally built, and that they had recently located documents indicating
that Respondents had been made aware of dangerous conditions at the
Subject Location.
1. The Zhengs’ New Evidence
a. Quiet Zone Study
The Zhengs attached a report from a Quiet Zone Study conducted in
2018 and 2019. The purpose of the study was to determine if it was feasible
to implement a quiet zone, in which train horns would be limited. The report
notes, “it could be challenging to keep pedestrians disembarking from a
trolley at the Washington Street Station from accessing the crossing during a
crossing signal activation as there is insufficient room to provide pedestrian
barriers.” Additionally, one representative noted “that an existing wall
between the LRT platform and the LOSSAN[8] tracks can block views of
oncoming trains.”
8 Los Angeles-San Diego-San Luis Obispo Rail Corridor.
16
The Zhengs also included an e-mail summarizing a site visit related to
the quiet zone proposal, in which a utilities engineer noted further, “Due to
the high frequency of trains and presence of 4 tracks, a second train may
often approach the crossing on a different track while the warning devices
remain activated. A number of approaches have very limited sight distance
toward approaching trains. The horn is a valuable safety measure in this
situation, particularly for pedestrians.”
b. The January 2013 CPUC Meeting
In addition, the Zhengs identified a letter from CPUC, produced by
MTS, describing a January 2013 meeting regarding safety concerns at the
Washington Street Station. According to the letter, “There have been four
incidents that occurred at this crossing within the past 5 years [since 2013],
the last 2 of which involved a pedestrian fatality, and a COASTER train
striking a semi-truck stopped over the tracks.”
The letter lists three “safety issues,” including: “Pedestrian
movements. Especially when there is both MTS and heavy rail traffic at the
same time. Pedestrian traffic at this grade crossing is heavy due to the
trolley station. To access other commuter bus facilities, pedestrians cross the
2 San Diego Subdivision tracks in which trains operate at maximum of 65
MPH. Fencing encloses the east and west station platforms along the north
segment of the 2 transit tracks; the west station fencing separates the trolley
station/tracks and San Diego Subdivision tracks. The fencing material is
solid stucco that acts as protective barrier, but presents significant reduction
17
in sightline distance and visibility.” CPUC recommended that the City
install “LOOK BOTH WAYS” markings on the sidewalk.9
c. Declaration of Lillian Zheng
Finally, Zheng’s daughter, Lillian Zheng submitted a declaration
describing changes made to the Washington Street Station after the Incident.
She stated that she visited the station on August 30, 2024 and “saw that the
masonry wall was dramatically changed and significantly lowered.” She
measured the wall and determined that it was approximately four feet high,
two feet lower than it was on the day of the Incident. She also provided
several photographs, attached as exhibits to her declaration.
2. Amended Opposition to Summary Judgment
The Zhengs relied on much of the same evidence in their amended
opposition to the motions for summary judgment. They asserted that
disputes remained regarding whether the Washington Street Station was as-
approved at the time of the Incident; whether the physical conditions at the
station had changed; whether changed circumstances rendered the original
design defective; and whether Respondents knew of the dangerous conditions
at the Subject Location.
With respect to changes at the station, the Zhengs asserted that the
Amtrak train that struck Zheng was being used as a southbound, or
alternating track at the time of the Incident, despite being approved as a
northbound track. In addition, they pointed to the removal of the “Watch for
Moving Trains” pavement stamp that pedestrians would previously cross
before reaching the heavy rail tracks. And they pointed to the lowering of the
9 A second version of this letter, dated March 15, 2013, appears in the
record as part of a lodgment of documents in support of Plaintiffs’ amended
opposition to the summary judgment motions. We will refer to these
collectively as “the CPUC meeting letter.”
18
masonry wall after the Incident as an admission that the design was
dangerous.
Regarding Respondents’ knowledge of the dangerous conditions, the
Zhengs relied on the Quiet Zone Study and also provided new evidence
regarding a fatality that occurred on August 26, 2022. They asserted that
“an elderly pedestrian proceeded westbound after a southbound train passed
and was struck by a second northbound train about 7 seconds later,”
highlighting “the dangers of multiple trains approaching in quick succession
and pedestrians’ difficulty in detecting trains from both directions.” In
addition, although there was no indication a trolley was involved in this
incident, a CPUC evaluator noted, “There are no flashers visible to
westbound pedestrians from the pedestrian storage area between the trolley
and the railroad tracks.”
The Zhengs asserted that once Respondents were put on notice of these
hazards, they had a duty to implement changes to address them within a
reasonable time. And they relied on Cameron v. State of California (1972)
7 Cal.3d 318 to argue that design immunity did not necessarily foreclose their
failure to warn claims.
3. Declaration of Louis D. Rubenstein
The Zhengs also submitted a declaration from their own expert
engineer, Louis D. Rubenstein, in support of their opposition. Rubenstein
opined that “it is evident that the Washington Street crossing poses
numerous dangerous conditions and fails to conform to multiple safety
standards and best practices for pedestrian-rail crossings.” He noted that
there were five fatalities and four injury incidents at the location between
1996 and February 2020, and provided copies of records from each
occurrence.
19
Rubenstein opined further that “[t]here is inadequate sight distance
due to a masonry wall on the subject platform that impedes pedestrians’
views of oncoming trains.” He noted that “The California Manual of Uniform
Traffic Control Devices . . . recommends a maximum fence height of 43
inches,” well below the 52-inch height of the wall at the time of the Incident.
Rubenstein also noted that “CPUC General Order 75-D states, ‘These
rules are not intended as complete design or construction specifications.
Design or construction specifications shall be in accord with accepted
industry standards for the given existing local conditions.’ ” He opined,
“When improvements to the station were made in 2010-2015 via the MTS and
SANDAG ‘Trolley Renewal Project,’ . . . a back-facing light was not, but
should have been, added to the Standard No. 8 flashing light signal in the
northwest corner of the crossing.” He also stated that NCTD’s decision to
allow bi-directional train travel made the original design of the location less
safe.
E. Respondents’ Supplemental Evidence
In a supplemental declaration, Miller responded to the Zhengs’ new
assertions, including those set forth in the Rubenstein declaration.
Miller described the prior fatalities at Washington Street Station. He
noted that in the first three instances, there was no indication that the
pedestrian came from the trolley platform. In the fourth, the deceased was a
“confirmed suicidal person,” and in the fifth, an individual was “dumped” out
of a wheelchair on the track by an acquaintance.
As particularly relevant to the issues on appeal, Miller stated: “Mr.
Rubenstein’s contention in paragraph 16 of his declaration that the design of
the masonry wall was not approved by MTS or a certified engineer is also
incorrect. The design specifications for the masonry wall at the Washington
Street Station are depicted on Drawing No. A-21 . . . in Volume II of the As-
20
Built Drawings re: The Old Town LRT Project. The drawings are stamped by
a registered landscape architect Michael A. Theilacker . . . in January 1993
and certified/approved by MTDB Project Engineer David Ragland . . . on
October 14, 1993. The As-Built Drawings were prepared by Parsons De
Leuw, Inc. and certified by City Engineer M. Sammak . . . on January 31,
1997.”
In addition, Miller noted that the Quiet Zone proposal was never
implemented, and opined that the findings in the report were therefore
irrelevant or immaterial to the instant matter. And he opined that “Multi-
directional operations on a track promote efficiency and allows flexibility in
responding to changing circumstances in the railroad industry.”
F. The Trial Court’s Ruling
After reviewing the various filings and hearing arguments from the
parties, the trial court granted the motions for summary judgment in favor of
MTS, NCTD, and SANDAG. The trial court determined that each of the
three entities were entitled to design immunity.
Regarding MTS, the trial court rejected Appellants’ argument that the
masonry wall was approved only by a landscape engineer, who did not fall
under the definition of “engineer” as required by statute. The court
concluded, “This position lacks merit as Plaintiffs do not dispute facts the
design and construction of the masonry wall were approved, inspected and
certified by design and civil engineers.” The court went on to find that MTS
met its initial burden to prove that the design and construction was
reasonable, and rejected Appellants’ assertion that MTS lost immunity due to
a change in physical condition. Finally, the court addressed Appellants’
argument that the station was a “concealed trap” by noting that a railroad
track is itself a warning of danger.
21
The trial court’s analysis of the motions for summary judgment filed by
NCTD and SANDAG was similar. As to NCTD, the court found that the
decision regarding the direction of train travel was reasonable and that it did
not constitute a change that eliminated design immunity. Likewise, the
court found that SANDAG reasonably followed the approved plans for the
station. The court noted that design immunity does not necessarily eliminate
failure to warn claims, but concluded that Appellants did not adequately
analyze the elements for the exception to apply.
The Zhengs filed a timely notice of appeal.
II. DISCUSSION
The Zhengs assert that the trial court erred by granting the summary
judgment motions because material issues of fact remain as to whether each
of the Respondents is entitled to design immunity and whether Respondents
lost design immunity because of changes or the passage of time. In addition,
the Zhengs assert their claims based on the alleged failure to warn of a
dangerous conditions are not excluded by design immunity, and that the trial
court failed to adequately address the concealment of critical documents.
A. Standard of Review
“The purpose of the law of summary judgment is to provide courts with
a mechanism to cut through the parties’ pleadings in order to determine
whether, despite their allegations, trial is in fact necessary to resolve their
dispute.” (Aguilar v. Atlantic Richfield Co. (2001) 25 Cal.4th 826, 843
(Aguilar). We review an order granting a motion for summary judgment de
novo and apply the same standards as the trial court. (Id. at p. 860.)
“[T]he party moving for summary judgment bears the burden of
persuasion that there is no triable issue of material fact and that he is
entitled to judgment as a matter of law.” (Aguilar, supra, 25 Cal.4th at
p. 850.) “There is a triable issue of material fact if, and only if, the evidence
22
would allow a reasonable trier of fact to find the underlying fact in favor of
the party opposing the motion in accordance with the applicable standard of
proof.” (Ibid.)
“Because summary judgment is defined by the material allegations in
the pleadings, we first look to the pleadings to identify the elements of the
causes of action for which relief is sought.” (Baptist v. Robinson (2006) 143
Cal.App.4th 151, 159.) “[T]he party moving for summary judgment bears an
initial burden of production to make a prima facie showing of the
nonexistence of any triable issue of material fact.” (Aguilar, supra,
25 Cal.4th at p. 850.) Where, as here, a party “moves for summary judgment
based on an affirmative defense, the [party] must show that undisputed facts
support each element of the affirmative defense.” (Tansavatdi v. City of
Rancho Palos Verdes (2021) 60 Cal.App.5th 423, 433 (Tansavatdi I), affirmed
by Tansavatdi v. City of Rancho Palos Verdes (2023) 14 Cal.5th 639
(Tansavatdi II).) “[I]f [the moving party] carries [their initial] burden of
production . . . the opposing party is then subjected to a burden of production
of [their] own to make a prima facie showing of the existence of a triable issue
of material fact.” (Aguilar, supra, 25 Cal.4th at p. 850.)
In determining whether the parties have met their respective burdens,
we “must ‘consider all of the evidence’ and ‘all’ of the ‘inferences’ reasonably
drawn therefrom [citation], and must view such evidence [citations] and such
inferences [citations], in the light most favorable to the opposing party.”
(Aguilar, supra, 25 Cal.4th at p. 843.)
B. Respondents Are Entitled to Design Immunity
Respondents’ primary contention, and the basis for the trial court’s
grant of summary judgment, is that they are each entitled to design
immunity under section 830.6.
23
“Under the Government Claims Act, ‘[a] public entity is not liable for
an injury,’ ‘[e]xcept as otherwise provided by statute.’ ” (Hampton v. County
of San Diego (2015) 62 Cal.4th 340, 347.) Section 835 provides that “a public
entity is liable for injury caused by a dangerous condition of its property if
the plaintiff establishes that the property was in a dangerous condition at the
time of the injury, that the injury was proximately caused by the dangerous
condition, that the dangerous condition created a reasonably foreseeable risk
of the kind of injury which was incurred, and that either: (a) A negligent or
wrongful act or omission of an employee of the public entity within the scope
of his employment created the dangerous condition; or (b) The public entity
had actual or constructive notice of the dangerous condition [as defined by
section 835.2] a sufficient time prior to the injury to have taken measures to
protect against the dangerous condition.”
However, section 830.6 creates an exception to that liability and states,
in relevant part: “Neither a public entity nor a public employee is liable
under this chapter for an injury caused by the plan or design of a
construction of, or an improvement to, public property where such plan or
design has been approved in advance of the construction or improvement by
the legislative body of the public entity or by some other body or employee
exercising discretionary authority to give such approval or where such plan
or design is prepared in conformity with standards previously so approved, if
the trial or appellate court determines that there is any substantial evidence
upon the basis of which (a) a reasonable public employee could have adopted
the plan or design or the standards therefor or (b) a reasonable legislative
body or other body or employee could have approved the plan or design or the
standards therefor.”
24
“The rationale for design immunity is to prevent a jury from second-
guessing the decision of a public entity by reviewing the identical questions of
risk that had previously been considered by the government officers who
adopted or approved the plan or design.” (Cornette v. Department of
Transportation (2001) 26 Cal.4th 63, 69 (Cornette).) “ ‘ “ ‘[T]o permit
reexamination in tort litigation of particular discretionary decisions where
reasonable men may differ as to how the discretion should be exercised would
create too great a danger of impolitic interference with the freedom of
decision-making by those public officials in whom the function of making
such decisions has been vested.’ ” ’ ” (Ibid.)
“[A] public entity claiming design immunity [under section 830.6] must
establish three elements: (1) a causal relationship between the plan or design
and the accident; (2) discretionary approval of the plan or design prior to
construction; and (3) substantial evidence supporting the reasonableness of
the plan or design.” (Cornette, supra, 26 Cal.4th at p. 69.)
“[T]he resolution of the third element of design immunity, the existence
of substantial evidence supporting the reasonableness of the adoption of the
plan or design, [is] a matter for the court, not the jury.” (Cornette, supra, 26
Cal.4th at p. 72.) “ ‘The trial court applies the deferential “substantial
evidence” standard traditionally employed by reviewing courts to determine
whether any reasonable state official could have approved the challenged
design.’ ” (Fuller v. Department of Transportation (2001) 89 Cal.App.4th
1109, 1113–1114 (Fuller).)
Because each of the Respondents were responsible for different
elements of the design, we address each in turn.
1. MTS
It is undisputed that MTS’s predecessor, MTDB, submitted the
application to CPUC to expand the light rail trolley system to include the
25
Washinton Street station, among others, and that CPUC issued a written
decision approving the proposal in 1994. MTS relies primarily on the
application and approval from CPUC to assert design immunity under
section 830.6. As we explain, MTS has presented evidence sufficient to
establish all three elements necessary for design immunity to apply.
a. Causation
MTS “may rely on the allegations of the complaint to establish
causation,” the first element necessary to establish design immunity. (Alvis
v. County of Ventura (2009) 178 Cal.App.4th 536, 550 (Alvis).) Here, the
Complaint alleges “the Subject Location had numerous dangerous
conditions,” including, as relevant to MTS, the masonry wall separating the
trolley track from the heavy rail tracks and the signage or warnings (or lack
thereof) alerting pedestrians to the second set of tracks. Likewise, the
allegations supporting each cause of action each include the same list of
alleged dangerous conditions created by the design, construction,
maintenance, and repair of the Washington Street Station.
The Zhengs argue that MTS failed to design measures to protect
pedestrians at the Washington Street Station and, specifically, that the
“design lacks any warning devices that face the trolley passengers on the
platform crossing the heavy rail tracks to indicate that an Amtrak train is
incoming.” However, it is undisputed that there are several warning devices
at the station, as required by CPUC regulations; that the masonry wall was
included in the design documents; and that the CPUC approved the proposal
which included both of these design elements.
“If, as [the Zhengs] suggest, [MTS] failed to prove the first element of
design immunity—causation—the result would not be that evidence of [these
design elements] would be admissible. Rather, without any causal
connection, evidence concerning [these design elements] would be completely
26
irrelevant and still properly excluded at trial. [The Zhengs] cannot now deny
the efficacy of their allegations.” (Fuller, supra, 89 Cal.App.4th at p. 1114.)
b. Discretionary Approval of the Design
As to the second element, discretionary approval, “a public entity ‘must
show that the design was approved “in advance” of the construction “by the
legislative body of the public entity or by some other body or employee
exercising discretionary authority to give such approval.” ’ ” (Tansavatdi I,
supra, 60 Cal.App.5th at p. 435.) “The entity must prove that the person or
entity who made the relevant decision is vested with the authority to make
it.” (Ibid.)
The following facts are undisputed: MTS is a public agency and its
predecessor was responsible for the design, construction, maintenance, and
repair of the Washington Street trolley station, including the allegedly
dangerous masonry wall and the allegedly inadequate warning signals at
issue in the asserted claims. The CPUC has jurisdiction over MTS, and had
jurisdiction over its predecessor MTDB. MTDB was authorized by statute “to
utilize and cross public streets or other public ways within the City of San
Diego and to construct and maintain an LRT system along with its
appurtenances, as well as to relocate other facilities necessary to
accommodate the LRT system.” MTDB filed an application with the CPUC to
add additional track and nine new stations, including the Washington Street
Station. The CPUC issued a written decision approving MTDB’s application
and noted that the proposed plans contained therein had been reviewed by
the CPUC’s Safety Division Traffic and Engineering staff. The approval also
noted that the application was in compliance with the CPUC’s requirements,
and that detailed drawings were included in the appendices.
As to the masonry wall specifically, MTS asserted further in its
separate statement of undisputed material facts: “With respect to the
27
Washington Street Station, design specifications were developed, reviewed
and approved by MTDB and CPUC as specified in As-Built Drawing Nos. A-
10, A-11, A-12, A-13 A-14 and A-15. A masonry separation wall separates the
west side of the station and the adjacent heavy rail tracks as documented on
As-Built Drawing Nos. A-20 and A-21. The masonry wall is designed,
approved and constructed per specifications. The wall is six (6) feet in height
which tailors down and ends at the south end of the station at or near the
public sidewalk. The purpose of the wall is to provide a barrier between the
station and adjacent heavy rail tracks to prevent patrons on the LRT
platform from being exposed to dust, debris and potential dragging
equipment from passing heavy rail trains. The masonry wall is part of the
original construction of the station and has existed without modification/
change by application of the CPUC or otherwise.” The Zheng’s disputed this
contention only to the extent that they alleged the wall was lowered after the
Incident.10
In addition, MTS provided copies of “as-built” drawings showing the
masonry wall in significant detail. Those drawings bear the date October 14,
1993, before the final approval from CPUC, stamped next to a box on each
page bearing registered engineer, Mark Randall’s name. The Zhengs assert
that the specific page showing the detail on the masonry wall bears only the
signature of a landscape engineer, but it is apparent that the same “Oct. 14
1993” stamp has been placed on the page, just below Ragland’s name, likely
because it did not fit in the provided box, which is notably smaller, on that
particular page.
10 MTS cites the Furey declaration as support for this contention. The
Zhengs assert that Furey did not list A-20 specifically as one of the as-built
diagrams approved by a certified engineer, but they fail to mention that
Furey does list A-21, which also shows detail of the masonry wall.
28
The Zhengs also rely on Business and Professions Code section 6735,
subdivision (a) which states, in relevant part, “All civil engineering plans and
specifications that are permitted or that are to be released for construction
shall bear the signature and seal or stamp of [a licensed civil engineer] and
the date of signing and sealing or stamping.” As an initial matter, although
difficult to read, there is a seal and stamp, with signature, on the first three
pages of the document. As the Zhengs assert, it does appear that the only
stamp on the individual page showing the details of the masonry wall belongs
to a landscape engineer, but each page does show the approval of several
other engineers, including Ragland. Finally, the Zhengs do not provide any
authority indicating that Business and Professions Code section 6735,
subdivision (a) requires a sign, seal, and stamp on every single page of a set
of design documents.
Given the detailed declaration submitted by civil engineer Furey, the
numerous undisputed factual contentions establishing that the CPUC
approved the design of the Washington Street Station after a complete
engineering review, and the additional pages demonstrating Ragland’s
review and approval of the as-built drawings, we conclude, as the trial court
did, that MTS has established that the design of the masonry wall was
approved by the appropriate legislative body (the CPUC) exercising its
discretionary authority to give such approval, as required to establish design
immunity. The mere fact that Ragland’s stamp or signature does not appear
on an individual page within the design documents is not sufficient to defeat
this conclusion. (See, e.g., Bane v. State of Cal. (1989) 208 Cal.App.3d 860,
868–869 [public entity can prove the requisite approval through testimony, in
the absence of the statutorily mandated signature].)
29
c. Reasonableness of the Design
As to the third element, we have no trouble concluding, as the trial
court did, that the design was reasonable. As noted, the reasonableness of
the design is a matter for the court, not the jury, and we apply a deferential
standard limited to whether any reasonable official could have approved the
challenged design. (See Cornette, supra, 26 Cal.4th at p. 72; Fuller, supra, 89
Cal.App.4th at pp. 1113–114.)
“ ‘Generally, a civil engineer’s opinion regarding reasonableness is
substantial evidence sufficient to satisfy this element. [Citation.] Approval
of the plan by competent professionals can, in and of itself, constitute
substantial evidence of reasonableness. [Citation.] That a plaintiff’s expert
may disagree does not create a triable issue of fact.’ ” (Tansavatdi I, supra,
60 Cal.App.5th at p. 439.)
Here, the proposal was approved by various engineers. It was then
approved by the CPUC, with the CPUC expressly stating that “the proposed
plans have been reviewed by the Commission’s Safety Division Traffic
Engineering Staff.” The Zhengs do not dispute that the CPUC had statutory
authority to approve the plans. Any assertion that the plans were not
reasonable “amounts to no more than disagreement with the [CPUC and
MTS] experts, who opined that the design of the intersection was
reasonable.” (Tansavatdi I, supra, 60 Cal.App.5th at p. 439.)
Based on the foregoing, we conclude that MTS is entitled to design
immunity under section 830.6, and that the Zhengs have not established a
triable issue of material fact regarding that immunity.
2. NCTD
It is undisputed that “MTS inspects, maintains and repairs the
warning devices on the east side of the safety wall at the trolley station.
NCTD does not own, operate or maintain the trolley station warning devices
30
or grade crossing warning devices on the east side of the wall. Those warning
devices are owned, operated and maintained by MTS.” However, NCTD does
inspect, maintain, and repair the warning devices on the west side of the
safety wall.
The Zhengs assert claims against NCTD for two reasons. First, they
assert that the train that struck Mr. Zheng was traveling southbound, which
was the opposite direction of the original design. Second, they allege the
track lacked adequate warning devices for pedestrians crossing the west side
of the track, which NCTD maintained.
As to the second contention, the Zhengs have not established that the
warning devices on NCTD’s side of the tracks were not included in the plans
submitted by MTS for expansion, which resulted in pedestrian traffic in the
median between the two sets of tracks in the first instance. While NCTD
admits that it maintains the warning devices on the west side of the safety
track, there is limited evidence regarding their installation. Further, it is
undisputed that Mr. Zheng (like any other pedestrian exiting the trolley)
could hear the bells ringing and see the flashing lights of the warning device
in the middle of the two sets of tracks. As shown in the photographs provided
by NCTD, that warning device is situated directly in front of a pedestrian
who reaches the end of the masonry wall. The design of the wall itself, and
the standard flashing light assembly facing the end of the wall were the
responsibility of MTS, and were subject to design immunity, as discussed
ante.
For the first time in their reply brief, the Zhengs rely on the
Rubenstein declaration to assert that the signal device on NCTD’s side of the
tracks should have had both back and forward lights. But Rubenstein relies
on recommendations issued in 2009 and 2012, long after the light rail tracks
31
and station were designed and installed. Regardless, the Zhengs do not
explain how lights across two sets of tracks would have provided any more
adequate warning than the flashing light assembly in the middle of the two
tracks, which a pedestrian like Mr. Zheng would necessarily face as he
walked along the masonry wall towards Washington Street, and which the
Zhengs concede was both sounding bells and flashing on the day of the
Incident.
Regarding the decision to allow trains to travel southbound on the
easternmost track, the first element of design immunity, causation, is met by
the pleadings, as it was with MTS. To the extent the Zhengs assert the
direction of travel played a role in causing Mr. Zheng’s death, causation is
established.
The second element of a discretionary decision is met by the declaration
of Scott Shroyer, who explained that there is “no federal rule, regulation or
standard that requires trains such as the COASTER commuter train to use a
specific track in areas where there are two or more parallel tracks” and that
the decision to permit southbound trains on the easternmost track “was
related to station and platform placement.”
The Zhengs do not offer any evidence to dispute Shroyer’s declaration,
or to establish that this was not a discretionary decision made by an
authorized individual at a public entity, nor do they offer any testimony
disputing the reasonableness of this decision. Rather, the only dispute they
raise in response to NCTD’s factual contention on this point was that there is
no train station (other than the trolley station) at the Washington Street
crossing, and thus presumptively there would be no need to route trains
based on station location. But of course, the trains cannot travel on different
32
tracks at different stations. If the direction of travel is important at any
station, it must be the same throughout the region.
At most, the Zhengs argue in their reply brief, that the Shroyer
declaration is insufficient insofar as it does not name a specific individual or
legislative body that approved the decision to allow trains to travel in this
manner. This is insufficient to defeat NCTD’s claim of design immunity.
Finally, as with MTS, the reasonableness of the discretionary decision
is a matter for the court. Here, it was reasonable for NCTD to allow
bidirectional travel, in accordance with the industry standard.
Based on the foregoing, we conclude that NCTD is entitled to design
immunity under section 830.6, to the limited extent that it played any role in
the design of the alleged dangerous conditions, and that the Zhengs have not
established a triable issue of material fact regarding that immunity.
3. SANDAG
SANDAG’s role in the design of the Washington Street Station was
even more limited. The Zheng’s contentions against SANDAG are limited to
the Trolley Renewal Project, during which SANDAG demolished and then
replaced a concrete slab at the end of the masonry wall, between the two sets
of tracks, and failed to replace a “Watch for Moving Trains” pavement
stamp.11
Gentile, the resident engineer for the project explained that the plans
for the modification were designed and drafted by the engineers at CH2M
Hill, and that he also reviewed the plans prior to construction. The plans
were based on the as-built drawings and did not include any pavement
11 The Zhengs also raised contentions regarding a “Look Both Ways” sign
affixed to the signal pole but do not dispute SANDAG’s contention that the
sign was not there when SANDAG began work on August 28, 2018.
33
stamp. The Zhengs do not provide any evidence establishing when or why
the “Watch for Moving Trains” pavement stamp was placed at the station.
Nor do they dispute SANDAG’s factual contentions that the sidewalk slab
complied with the as-built plans, which did not call for such a stamp, and
that SANDAG never received any complaint about the allegedly missing
stamp.12
Based on the foregoing, we conclude that SANDAG is entitled to design
immunity under section 830.6, to the limited extent that it played any role in
the design of the alleged dangerous conditions, and that the Zhengs have not
established a triable issue of material fact regarding that immunity.
C. Respondents Did Not Lose Design Immunity
The Zhengs contend that even if they had design immunity at one
point, each of the Respondents lost the immunity before the Incident occurred
due to changes to the original design, including the approval for heavy rail
trains to run southbound on the track closest to the trolley station, and the
addition and then removal of the “Watch for Moving Trains” pavement
stamp.
“[T]o demonstrate loss of design immunity a plaintiff must establish
three elements: (1) the plan or design has become dangerous because of a
change in physical conditions; (2) the public entity had actual or constructive
notice of the dangerous condition thus created; and (3) the public entity had a
reasonable time to obtain the funds and carry out the necessary remedial
work to bring the property back into conformity with a reasonable design or
plan, or the public entity, unable to remedy the condition due to practical
12 Notably, to the extent the “WATCH FOR MOVING TRAINS” sidewalk
stamp was present in 2019, Mr. Zheng would have seen it on previous trips.
34
impossibility or lack of funds, had not reasonably attempted to provide
adequate warnings.” (Cornette, supra, 26 Cal.4th at p. 72.)
As an initial matter, we note that the Zhengs seem to conflate the first
and second elements of the loss of design immunity analysis. It is not enough
that Respondents had actual or constructive notice of any alleged dangerous
condition; rather, they must have notice that a change in physical condition
created a dangerous condition. In other words, the notice must be tied to the
change. Here, the only changes the Zhengs rely upon are the approval for
trains to run southbound on the first heavy rail track and the placement and
then removal of the “Watch for Moving Trains” pavement stamp. The Zhengs
do not establish that the change in direction of travel of the trains on the
adjacent heavy rail tracks was a physical change. Nor do they connect their
various allegations about Respondents’ alleged notice regarding the
dangerous conditions at the Washington Street Station to these specific
changed conditions.
Regarding the direction of train travel, Shroyer stated that “NCTD’s
COASTER commuter train has operated north/south train service between
the Oceanside Transit Center and the Santa Fe Depot in downtown San
Diego” since 1995. Both COASTER and Amtrak train routes place
southbound trains on the easternmost track (MT 1) and northbound trains on
the westernmost track (MT 2). NCTD gave discretionary approval for to the
plan to have southbound COASTER trains use the easternmost track where
there are two parallel tracks in approximately 2018. MTDB completed the
work on the Old Town LRT Extension Project in June 1996, and received
authorization from CPUC to commence service that same month.
The Zhengs have presented no evidence regarding the direction of train
travel on the heavy rail tracks adjacent to the Washington Street Station
35
before 2018, or, more specifically, in or around the time the Washington
Street Station was designed and approved, nor have they established that the
travel of direction was a consideration in the discretionary decision to include
the masonry wall in the station design. To the contrary, here, Shroyer
explained that the custom and practice was not to restrict bilateral
movement where two sets of tracks were present. Moreover, the change in
the direction of travel on a particular track, if it was a change at all, is not a
change in physical condition of the public property. (See Dammann v. Golden
Gate Bridge, Highway & Transportation Dist. (2012) 212 Cal.App.4th 335,
353 [changed physical condition requires “changes in the physical conditions
of the public property at issue that produce a dangerous condition related to
the plan or design at issue”]; Wyckoff v. State (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 45, 60
[“increase in traffic volume did not constitute a changed condition”].) Finally,
although the Zhengs presented evidence that the presence of four tracks in
close proximity and limited sight lines had been mentioned as concerns, they
did not establish that the direction of travel of the trains was considered as a
factor, and, in any event, the CPUC meeting letter was dated 2013, prior to
the alleged change.
Likewise, as noted, the Zhengs have not offered any evidence
establishing when the WATCH FOR TRAINS pavement stamp was added,
and thus cannot establish that the removal of the stamp was a change that
resulted in a dangerous condition after the approval of the design for the
station. The Zhengs baldly assert that the “pavement markings were added
by MTS in response to the new hazards not considered in the original design”
but notably offer no evidentiary support for that assertion.
36
D. The Zhengs Did Not Establish an Independent Failure to Warn
Claim
The Zhengs rely on Tansavatdi II to assert that even if Respondents
were entitled to design immunity, that immunity did not immunize them
from liability based on their failure to warn about the dangerous conditions
at the Washington Street Station. They argue, as they did in the trial court,
that the Washington Street Station posed a concealed trap because: 1) the
lights activated for the trolley and did not warn of additional incoming train
traffic; 2) there were no flashers facing pedestrians as they crossed the heavy
rail tracks; 3) and the masonry wall obstructed the view. They argue further
that the design did not account for “the change in train traffic, lack of
warning signs, or that warning signals were triggered only by the trolley.”
And they rely on the Quiet Zone Study and the CPUC meeting letter as
evidence that Respondents had notice of the dangerous condition at the
Washington Street Station. However, as we explain, the Zhengs focus much
of their argument on the alleged dangerous condition created by the wall and
fail to explain how the absence of a warning, not part of the original design,
was a substantial, independent factor in causing the Incident.
1. The Tansavatdi Cases
We begin with a discussion of the Tansavatdi line of cases. In
Tansavatdi II, our high court addressed the question of whether a
determination that a public entity is entitled to design immunity under
section 830.6 also “categorically precludes any claim that the public entity is
liable for having failed to warn of a dangerous traffic condition resulting from
that approved design.” (Tansavatdi II, supra, 14 Cal.5th at p. 652.)
As the court in Tansavatdi II explained, section 835 creates “two
distinct grounds for dangerous conditions liability”: “liability for injuries
caused by a dangerous condition that a public entity created (§ 835, subd. (a));
37
and liability for failing to protect against a dangerous condition of which the
public entity had notice (id., subd. (b).).” (Tansavatdi II, supra, 14 Cal.5th at
p. 659.) “[T]hese two distinct theories of liability incorporated the ‘active’ and
‘passive’ theories of negligence recognized in the common law.” (Ibid.)
“[S]ection 830.6 immunizes liability for having created a dangerous
traffic condition under section 835, subdivision (a) (a form of active
negligence) but does not necessarily immunize liability for failing to warn of a
known dangerous traffic condition under section 835, subdivision (b) (a form
of passive negligence).” (Id. at p. 660.) However, “to prevail on a claim under
subdivision (b), the plaintiff must prove the public entity had notice of the
dangerous condition.” (Ibid.)
In addition, “[s]ection 830.8 provides a second form of immunity,
precluding public entity liability ‘for an injury caused by the failure to
provide traffic or warning signals, signs, markings or devices described in the
Vehicle Code.’ (§ 830.8.) Section 830.8, however, sets forth a limitation to
such immunity: ‘Nothing in this section exonerates a public entity . . . from
liability for injury . . . caused by such failure if a signal, sign, marking or
device . . . was necessary to warn of a dangerous condition which endangered
the safe movement of traffic and which would not be reasonably apparent to,
and would not have been anticipated by, a person exercising due care.’ This
limitation to section 830.8 immunity is commonly referred to as the
‘concealed trap’ exception.” (Tansavatdi II, supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 654, 660.)
As the court explained, “ ‘[t]he rationale for design immunity is to
prevent a jury from second-guessing the decision of a public entity by
reviewing the identical questions of risk that had previously been considered
by the government officers who adopted or approved the plan or design.’ ”
(Tansavatdi II, supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 653–654.) That rational may not
38
immunize a government entity from the more passive type of negligence in
section 835, subdivision (b) but, to prevail on this type of claim “for failing to
warn of a dangerous traffic condition that is otherwise subject to design
immunity, the plaintiff must prove the absence of a warning was an
‘independent, separate, concurring cause of the accident.’ ” (Tansavatdi II, at
p. 661.)
Of particular relevance here, the Tansavatdi II court went on to explain
that it expressly had not “address[ed] whether design immunity might apply
if the public entity is able to show that the presence or absence of warning
signs was part of the approved design.” (Tansavatdi II, supra, 14 Cal.5th at
p. 661.) But the court did clarify that, even if a plaintiff were able to pursue a
failure to warn claim, they “must nonetheless prove various elements that
are not present when pursuing a claim alleging a public entity created that
dangerous condition:” 1) “actual or constructive notice that the approved
design resulted in a dangerous condition,” 2) “a concealed trap,” and 3) “the
absence of a warning was a substantial factor in bringing about the injury.”
(Id. at pp. 661–662.)
On remand, the trial court granted a second motion for summary
judgment, concluding that the design immunity at issue in Tansavatdi did
also apply to the failure to warn claim because the original design included
warning signs about the alleged dangerous condition. (Tansavatdi v. City of
Rancho Palos Verdes (2026) 123 Cal.App.5th 654, 664 (Tansavatdi III).)
While the present appeal was pending, the Court of Appeal affirmed
the trial court’s grant of summary judgment. (Tansavatdi III, 123
Cal.App.5th at p. 689.) In doing so, the court set forth the following “limited”
rule: “when (a) there is some warning of the relevant dangerous condition
provided as part of (b) an approved design, but (c) the plaintiff claims that
39
additional or different warnings were necessary, such claims may be barred
by design immunity (assuming that all the other requirements of design
immunity are met).” (Id. at pp. 675–676.) The court explained that this was
consistent with prior authority that design immunity “ ‘ “does not immunize
from liability caused by negligence independent of design.” ’ ” (Id. at p. 673.)
Where warnings are part of the original design, and the only question is the
adequacy of those warnings, any associated alleged negligence is not
independent of the design. (Ibid.)
In addition, the court explained that a case where there was no
warning at all is categorically different from one in which the issue is
whether a given warning was adequate. (Tansavatdi III, 123 Cal.App.5th at
p. 677.) In the latter case, the jury would be asked to answer questions
regarding the “best form of a potential warning,” which would “interfere with
significant infrastructure planning decisions made by governments. Design
immunity, when it applies, reserves such decisions to public officials, not the
courts.” (Id. at pp. 677–678.)
Finally, the court clarified an important point: “even when design
immunity applies, a public entity may have a duty to provide warnings when
changed physical conditions or other circumstances have caused the design to
become dangerous—consistent with the ordinary rules for design immunity.
If changed physical conditions have caused the design of a warning to no
longer be reasonable, the existing parameters of design immunity already
restrict its application.” (Tansavatdi III, 123 Cal.App.5th at p. 680.) In those
cases, section 830.8 would still provide signage immunity, unless the plaintiff
proved that there was a concealed trap, a dangerous condition that would not
be anticipated by a person using reasonable care. (Tansavatdi III, at p. 681.)
40
2. The Zhengs Have Not Established a Concealed Trap or
That the Lack of an Additional Warning Was a Substantial
Factor in the Incident
Here, as in Tansavatdi, Respondents assert that there were multiple
warning signs included as a part of the initial design of the Washington
Street Station. Most notably, as depicted in the image below (a still taken
from the video just before the Incident occurred), at the time of the accident,
there was a standard 8 flashing light assembly at the end of the sidewalk
separating the two sets of tracks, facing toward the pedestrian sidewalk, with
flashing lights, clanging bells, and a sign that read “Railroad Crossing Two
Tracks.”
Any pedestrian exiting the trolley and walking along the masonry wall
towards the Washington Street crossing, including Mr. Zheng, would
necessarily face this warning throughout the length of the walk, and just
before reaching the end of the masonry wall. Critically, this light assembly
was included in the original proposal and plans for the Washington Street
Station approved by the CPUC.
41
To the extent the Zhengs now assert this warning was not adequate to
alert such pedestrians of the presence of trains on the adjacent heavy rail
tracks, that argument seems to fall in the category of cases discussed in
Tansavatdi in which the issue is whether a given warning was adequate.
(Tansavatdi III, 123 Cal.App.5th at p. 677.) But either way, to pursue a
claim for failure to warn, the Zhengs would need to establish notice, a
concealed trap, and that “the absence of a warning was a substantial factor in
bringing about the injury.” (Tansavatdi II, supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 661–662.)
The Zhengs rely on the Quiet Zone Study notes and the CPUC meeting
letter to assert that Respondents had notice of the dangerous condition of
pedestrians leaving the trolley and crossing the second set of tracks without
warning that a second train may be coming, and assert that Respondents
failed to address that specific dangerous condition in a reasonable amount of
time.
As an initial matter, we note that the evidence establishes that the
quiet zone was never implemented. As much of the discussion in that study
was centered around the changed condition of reducing train horns, which
did not occur, it is of minimal relevance to the question of whether
Respondents had notice regarding any alleged concealed trap. However, we
do acknowledge that the CPUC meeting letter discusses ongoing safety
concerns at the Washington Street Station, which became apparent after the
implementation of the original design, including the fact that the masonry
wall might obstruct the ability of passengers exiting a trolley or at the trolley
station to see oncoming trains on the second set of heavy rail tracks.
Regardless, though, even if we were to conclude that the Zhengs had
established that Respondents were on notice of this specific danger, and that
the immunity for the original design did not fully immunize them from a
42
failure to warn claim, the Zhengs still have not established the additional
elements of a concealed trap or that the lack of some additional warning was
a substantial factor in bringing about the Incident. (See Tansavatdi II,
supra, 14 Cal.5th at pp. 661–662; Tansavatdi III, 123 Cal.App.5th at p. 681.)
Here, the trial court concluded that the Zhengs could not establish that
the second set of railroad tracks was a “concealed trap.” Rather, as the trial
court explained “[a] railroad track is itself a warning of danger and a driver
intending to cross must avail himself of every opportunity to look and listen;
if there are obstructions to the view, he is required to take greater care.”
(Wilkinson v. Southern Pac. Co. (1964) 224 Cal.App.2d 478, 488.)
The Zhengs assert that the masonry wall impeded vision of the second
set of tracks, and that the warning signals—including the warning bells and
the standard 8 flashing light assembly at the end of the trolley station
sidewalk—were alerting pedestrians to the trolley’s arrival at the station,
and were not adequate to warn those same pedestrians of the additional
Amtrak train. But as noted at the outset of this discussion, a pedestrian
walking along the masonry wall would certainly see both sets of railroad
tracks straight ahead, as well as the standard 8 flashing light assembly.
While the pedestrian may not be aware of how many trains are on the tracks
at one time, or which direction they may be traveling, a person using
reasonable care would certainly be aware of the inherent dangers of the
railroad crossing and the readily visible tracks on either side of the
pedestrian walkway, and would pause to look before stepping out onto the
second set of tracks. (See Tansavatdi III, 123 Cal.App.5th at p. 677.
Likewise, given the speed at which Zheng moved past the end of the wall and
onto the tracks, without pausing to look, a factfinder could not reasonably
conclude that the lack of any additional warning sign, such as the WATCH
43
FOR TRAINS pavement stamp, was a substantial factor in bringing about
the Incident.
For these reasons, we conclude that the Zhengs have not established a
failure to warn claim that is not excluded by Respondents’ design immunity.
E. The Alleged Concealment of Critical Documents
As a final matter, the Zhengs assert that the trial court erred by
granting summary judgment because MTS did not produce the stamped
copies of “as-built” drawings showing the masonry wall in significant detail
until September 24, 2024. It appears that MTS produced those documents in
part in response to the Zhengs’ contentions that the previously produced
application and approval were not sufficient to establish design immunity. In
any event, discovery was ongoing, and the Zhengs provide no authority
establishing that the trial court erred by granting summary judgment
because of the timing of the production of these documents.
III. DISPOSITION
The judgments are affirmed. Respondents are entitled to costs on appeal.
KELETY, J.
WE CONCUR:
O’ROURKE, Acting P. J.
DATO, J.
44